I too like the magic links. I've been an advocate for them in our tech stack ever since the first one I used on Slack. Yes, it's a paradigm shift, but I don't think that's a reason to avoid using it.

My team is split on whether or not they are a good thing, but the main reason people usually give against magic links are it's too cumbersome to go find it in your email. Am I the only one who always has email open?

From an implementation standpoint has anyone seen a negative consequence of using magic links? I know password resets are always a portion of our customer service handling – is there an equivalent with magic links?

For my mother-in-law who can't keep her single, reused-everywhere password straight, magic links approximate a miracle. I wish Skype used them so we could save 15 minutes every time we want to video call.

I'm surprised to see someone likes them, but after all there must be a reason if they exist. As someone who uses LastPass for pretty much every online form, I deeply hate magic login emails.

I'm fine with them existing, as long as you keep the classic email/password option. Something that usually takes me at most 5 seconds (wait for page to load and for LastPass to fill the fields, then click) ends up being a 30+seconds matter. How is this not terrible user experience???

You might be the only one...