Hacker News Reader

Comment by napoleond | Hacker News Reader

AFAIK, oData only lets you request a single entity type at a time, doesn't it? For example, in the example you provided, would it be possible to fetch a collection of People and Airports as part of the same request? What would that request look like?

View on HN

You can include associated entities by using expand, e.g. order with orderlines. See: https://www.odata.org/getting-started/basic-tutorial/#expand

The oData contract, $metadata, describes an entire domain model, including associations between entities. You can use expand to join entities over these associations.

You can request multiple queries in one http operation using batch requests: https://www.odata.org/getting-started/advanced-tutorial/#bat...

No, you can query a collection of these entities and get back the resulting set with pagination.

No, you can batch requests.

The question was not about batching, it was about join queries over more than one resource type.

I guess I should be more clear...

batch means you can do things like combine these:

GET /serviceRoot/Airports GET /serviceRoot/People

into one request (and get the results in one response)

I believe that's what the poster was asking.

Here's a link to a different example from the OData site: https://www.odata.org/getting-started/advanced-tutorial/#bat...

You're using the word "join". I'm not sure if you meant that in a relational sense or not. If yes, then maybe you're wondering if you can get airports with their related people, or people with their related airports in one request with OData. Again, the answer is yes.

Thanks for the explanation!

No problem... I realize my initial answer was pretty useless. "batch" has a specific meaning in Odata but of course you wouldn't know that unless you already knew Odata.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com