Hacker News Reader

Comment by oblio | Hacker News Reader

> EU response to this is various EU funding programs that are mostly throwing money away for little to no benefit.

You're framing this as if it's the EU's job. It isn't.

The only way the EU could compete if it would become a federal state, similar to the US. Right now the EU, despite being a single market in many respects is far from being a true digital single market.

Individual states are actively fighting against this because they would have give up bits of their sovereignty (controlling tax levels, such as VAT, commercial legislation, etc.).

You can't both have your cake (a huge single market able to funnel huge amounts of money into your desired investments) and eat it (keep total control of your country's finances).

View on HN

> Right now the EU, despite being a single market in many respects is far from being a true digital single market

I think this is less about regulations and more about language. Most people in the EU simply don't speak english so you would have to have your marketing and sales in 20 languages which is simply not doable. A french startup just can't cold call a romanian company because they can not communicate. Yes, it gets better with each new generation but it will be decades before this is "solved".

How do these things get realized in the EU system ? I mean hypothetically if Germany, France, Netherlands, the Nordic countries pass legislations for greater integration wouldnt others follow suite ? Should it also not pass easily since most big businesses would probably get behind it ?

You're forgetting that Europeans are overall fiercely nationalistic by modern standards (not-WW1 nationalistic, but still).

Every EU country pushes back when there are attempts for more integration. More than that, there's a rising anti-EU current in most EU countries, due to various population movement issues.

> You're framing this as if it's the EU's job. It isn't.

Then what is EU Horizon 2020 for?

https://ec.europa.eu/programmes/horizon2020/what-horizon-202...

An attempt.

But the EU budget is much, much smaller than the US federal budget:

EU: $150 billion for 2014

US: $3000 billion for 2014

And the barriers between national markets in the EU are much steeper than the ones between state markets in the US.

150 billion i still a good amount of money. The problem with EU funding is in the objectives:

- Vaguely defined, so they open a lot of room for lobbying and corruption

- It is hard to align them to a startup agenda and the administrative overhead is often prohibitive

I wish it was more like a venture fund, but one that doesn't take equity.

Just my two cents.

Those goals are vaguely defined because they're a compromise. The EU generally works by consensus, they're trying to herd 28 (soon to be 27) cats.

And it is a legal liability as you can quickly get investigated for misspending the funds.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com