Hacker News Reader

Comment by kharms | Hacker News Reader

In my experience they over-optimized, with homepod now responding to "hey Sara" instead of Siri. Drives my partner nuts.

View on HN

"Hey Sara" makes sense to me. Sort of. Because there's at least a "Hey" trigger.

Why my wife's iPhone responds every time she says, "Are you serious?" makes less sense. Especially since the response from Siri doesn't show her inquiry string on the screen, just Siri's response, which is usually, "I'm always serious."

That's because people have accents.

My partner is Korean and I am Australian for example. Two very different approaches to speaking English.

You would hope that the HomePod would be usable by both of us.

If you have a HomePod, try saying "Hey, Hugh!". I'm getting false positives with 'strayan accent.

We've been getting lots of false positives, as well, but it seems to have started happening suddenly. I wonder if it's related to a recent software update.

We often get false positives as well. I've wished there were some way to signal a false positive to the device after Siri is activated, like "Siri, I didn't ask for you," to help it learn/train it. Not sure how feasible such a function would be, but I imagine it would be helpful feedback down the line on the engineering end. Anything to reduce the false positives would be great as they are a) a nuisance and b) further confirmation to friends/family who witness it, that we've made a mistake allowing a "surveillance" device in our home.

I would guess that they are inferring this based on whether the device gets another request in rapid succession.

Have you noticed that certain queries that used to work have stopped giving you the expected response?

I've started noticing more false positives since iOS 12 launched, and there's a couple requests that now don't give me the expected response. The most annoying issue happens to be requesting Siri to set an alarm. I'll ask: "Hey Siri, turn on my 6:15am alarm." to which she'll respond, "Which alarm do you want to turn on..." and then list all the different alarms I've set on the HomePod.

This all changed with iOS 12, and I wonder if I should reach out to Apple or just live with it and hope it improves with a software update??

If you think about what you asked Siri it's a sensible response.

You didn't ask her to set an alarm for 6:15am. You asked her to turn on an existing 6:15am alarm.

Which since I am assuming it didn't exist Siri asked what others you did want to turn on.

Late response, but here's the thing...that alarm does exist and is listed off when Siri goes through all the existing alarm options that can be turned on...

Haven't noticed certain commands no longer working, personally.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com