Hacker News Reader

Comment by monocasa | Hacker News Reader

When there's somewhere between 500k->1m of them, it's very different then the occasional one off.

And that guy was approached by DEA agents posing as Taliban, so his connections are specious at best.

Right. With so many of them, it would be worth opening a public conversation. Inform people about the issues and the law process involved. Maybe start international topic of the issues if the involved people could create a small country on their own.

In short - they could do exactly the opposite of secret prisons without trials.

I'm not asking what they "should" do; I'm asking what literally any other country would do, especially the US.

Why? This article is not about the US. It would be pure speculation and largely irrelevant.

Because it's extremely worrying to me when there's a media blitz from one geopolitical sphere of influence about the actions of another sphere, when those exact actions have happened in the past in the first sphere, and as far as we can tell would happen in the future. That generally gets used to harm way more people than the original action.

You'll find the same criticism of interning Japanese people, US black sites abroad, and many other issues both in general media and posted on HN. This is no sudden media blitz. Just discussing current issues (camps in China are the topic here) rather than speculating over possible one.

Where exactly are those extremely polished single page apps from the BBC, Reuters, and CNN detailing the scope and scale of CIA blacksites?

One Google away - this is a lazy question. First link: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2017/oct/...

You can find the rest. (There are more)

Because if someone tells me not to do X, yet he himself would do X in the same circumstances, that's reason to think his behavior does not stem from a sincere moral conviction but is a cynical attempt to manipulate me?

You just assume every Muslim in that region is a terrorist? Based on what exactly?

Where do I or China say that? It's single digit percentages of Uighur that are interned, and the governor and large portions of the police of the region are Uighur.

This is exactly the kind of fundamental misconception of the situation that's particularly terrifying to me.

It didn't help that "China is locking up Uighurs" is the news title used everywhere.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com