Perhaps I was unduly harsh, but I disagree that I was shallow. I pointed out exactly where the problems lay; poor use of language and people operating outside of their domain of expertise.
I don't see any information in what you posted, just the most cliché of all dismissals in that category. That seems to me to be covered by what the guidelines call shallow. We don't need another boring "oh the humanities" go-round on Hacker News, even though some writers have problems with plain language.