US is 8 and UK 16 for starting a business. What does that mean? It's hard/easy to incorporate? It's incredibly easy to create a Limited company in the UK or LLC, S or C corp in the USA. (I've inc'd in both countries). What does the number 1 country have that US or UK doesn't have?
Paying taxes in the USA is 61 vs South Africa's 23? No way. Paying your taxes in South Africa is a serious pain in the behind - I continue to do it. We file our USA C corp and personal corp taxes ourselves each year and it's a breeze in the States.
My guess is this is based on public opinion with a relatively small sample size per country.