Hacker News Reader

This won’t be a problem much longer: https://blog.emojipedia.org/all-major-vendors-commit-to-gun-...

Sometimes you gotta break a few eggs to make change …

How is this not a problem anymore? The Unicode standard spells out 'PISTOL'. Not 'WATER GUN'. They are just collectively not compliant to the standard. Why don't they just introduce 'WATER GUN' as a brand new code point and remove 'PISTOL' from their chat apps' emoji selection?

Sadly dumbed down to waterpistol instead of what it should be, a "pistol".

Showing a revolver is not a display of extreme intellect, so it cannot really be dumbed down. It also shouldn't be sadly, as it's an emoji.

What do you mean? This symbol was change in its meaning, I find that sad.

It might be a sad decision to make, but nothing was 'dumbed down'.

IMHO the 'correct' solution, if you want to remove the handgun picture is to remove it from the emoji keyboard (and possibly refuse to render it) and introduce a new water pistol emoji.

I'm pretty sure users will just learn to interpret it as a pistol, rather than water gun. Same like how the eggplant emoji means "penis" now.

Besides, a small watergun graphic is just an often futuristic looking gun with neon colors. Hardly something that suddenly is unambiguously not a killing device.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com