Hacker News Reader

It sounds like for China's Muslim extremists and terrorists in prison, if it gets worse, they will almost have it as bad as the Muslim extremists and terrorists the US waterboards in Guantanamo Bay or black-op sites have it. Of course they're not nabbed from other countries, are given trials and so forth. If they keep this up, the Chinese will become as bad as the West.

View on HN

You're invoking a logical fallacy know as whataboutism[0]. The actions of the west cannot justify the imprisonment of hundreds of thousands by the chinese government.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism

The parent didn't justify anything.

[flagged]

i believe they were refering to the part in the previous post that said "a logical fallacy". to be a logical fallacy requires that something be used in a logical construction (hence the name). this is where "justify" has relevance.

for example, ad hominem is not a "logical fallacy" unless it is used in some kind of logical construct (such as a syllogism). it's not necessarily a "logical fallacy" to just simply insult someone in some subjective or qualitative way.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com