Hacker News Reader

Even if the swatting results in the death of an innocent person? That's the point with Barriss, as this incident resulted in the death of an innocent man. Cretins might enjoy calling in fake reports of hostage situations and watching the police reaction.; but, when people die, the situation and penalty are different. The penalties for driving drunk and killing someone are harsher than a simple DUI.

View on HN

Yes, even if the swatting results in the death of an innocent person.

> The penalties for driving drunk and killing someone are harsher than a simple DUI.

The penalties are harsher because they are different crimes. That's not an argument for executing prank callers.

> The penalties for driving drunk and killing someone are harsher than a simple DUI.

Even in this example, drunk drivers who kill aren't executed. I definitely agree the punishment on this particular individual should be stronger but executing him? That's taking it a bit far.

A long jail stint (and some growing up) would likely stop this particular individual from ever repeating their actions again. Executions should be reserved for those who are truly beyond rehabilitation IMO.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com