Hacker News Reader

Comment by preordained | Hacker News Reader

If you're taking off for vacation and forgot to lock your door, the best thing would be to go back and lock it. If you couldn't get the door locked right away for some reason, you probably wouldn't want the news of your unlocked door broadcast through your neighborhood...

Obscurity actually is a layer of security. The mistake is is when people are dependent upon it.

View on HN

Your analogy is severely flawed as my door lock is under my control and I know about the risks (i.e it is unlocked) so I can take the steps I need to mitigate that risk

For your analogy to apply here it would be the manufacturer of the door lock having a master key stolen then not telling anyone about it until they have a new lock for you to buy from them, in the case of a lock I would want to know that the lock is useless even if there was not solution so I can mitigate the risk no simply continue locking it believing it to be secure

Locksmiths can get into many locks that people use to secure their houses. That doesn't mean that I want them to share that knowledge widely.

Eh, that information is shared widely. Some decent googl-fu will get you the information you want.

The difference is a lock-pick can't exploit 20,000 doors in 20 minutes.

There are definitely bypass tools for common lock mechanisms, whose mechanism of operation isn't readily google-able.

And you still have to visit those, one at a time, in person where things like getting shot could occur.

I want them to. This puts more pressure for locks to improve and makes it less likely that I trust my current lock.

I see so now we are advocating for the suppression of Speech... Because how else are you going to prevent that? Pretty sure there are 100's of youtube vidoes on lock picking, you want to ban all of them?

But this isn't one persons' door that's unlocked. This is more like a company that shipped a faulty door lock and is trying to keep it secret until they can ship fixed doors to everybody.

But wouldn't you want to know if your door is faulty, so you can either replace your door, delay your vacation until the new door arrives, or beef up your security system?

Absolutely!

Reply on news.ycombinator.com