Comment by freedomben | Hacker News Reader

Comment by freedomben | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

I completely agree with this blog post, but every time I hear these sorts of things from Github it always begs the same question:

If you believe in open source so much, why is Github a closed-source product?

Many businesses, particularly SaaS businesses, have managed to be hugely profitable while making their code open source, so I don't accept the argument there.

And considering that the choices of many open source projects to host there and standardize on the Github ecosystem were a big factor in enabling GH to become what they are today, at some point I would feel an obligation.

It's their business and they can run it how they see fit, but it's something that has always bothered me.

Does a company have to open source their entire product to meet with your approval? It sounds like you're completely unaware they do open source large internal projects and hire people from community projects.

EDIT: also, Git is completely open source, and all of the data stored on GitHub can be exported. A lot of other tools even import data directly from GitHub. There's literally nothing stopping people from moving except that they want to use it.

> Does a company have to open source their entire product to meet with your approval?

Not OP, but it does seem a little hypocritical to demand others completely open source their projects while still holding onto proprietary software.

I'm not sure how GitHub demands that you open source anything. You can keep projects private if you want to keep them private.

While I agree with your sentiment, I think it would be difficult for GitHub to open-source their product.

The limitation for them is obviously their enterprise offerings, which would be far less profitable if businesses could just roll their own GitHub instance.

I thought about it and couldn't come up with many SaaS companies that are open-source. Especially not with the same business model as GitHub.

I too would love an open-source version, but for the reasons above I doubt it will happen.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com