Hacker News Reader

Hacker News

Comment by baursak | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

baursak

Why did you change the original NYT title, which is "Silicon Valley’s Politics: Liberal, With One Big Exception"?

What on Earth is "Far Left"? Surely Silicon Valley's politics are nowhere near Marxist or anarchist.

EDIT: apologies, you obviously didn't change it.

View on HN

It was the NYT that changed it, not the poster on HN.

The NYT changes headlines constantly, it's actually sort of fascinating to watch in real time, which you can do by following this automated Twitter account: https://twitter.com/nyt_diff/status/905407322658402304

Damn dude, awesome work finding this.

Completely changes the dynamic of the accusation above.

It seems NYT follows the "post now, edit later" approach

It could be worse than "post now, edit later".

The author could propose a list of a few possible headlines, say 10, each more or less urging/click-baity/informative. Then let an algorithm choose the most click-baity headline as visitors click on the headlines in ads or in Google news (using AB tests or multi-arn bandit algorithms).

I don't know if any news site does this yet, but it could explain the increase of click-baity or uninformative headlines in Google news.

WaPo AB uses a tool called Bandito to do just this: http://www.niemanlab.org/2016/02/how-the-washington-post-bui...

Ars Technica A/B tests their headlines.

I wonder if it's even really about the editing process. It seems possible to me that they intentionally start with a more provocative headline to get more early traction for an article, and then switch to the more neutral title as an article gains views. I could even imagine it being A/B tested early to see which headline will get them the most shares.

In addition to the usual copyedit tweaks, headlines are the thing that editors are more likely to go in and make more attention-grabbing, even if they become less neutrally factual in the process. This isn't really anything new although of course historically it was done before the issue actually went to press.

all news sites do this now.

Oh wow, thanks! Apologies to GP.

one additional reason not to feed that clickbait machine

excellent research to find that link!

OP here. I was hesitant about the title, and I actually originally posted something less inflammatory (didn't say "far left"). But then I figured I'd directly copy the NYT title, so I wouldn't be accused of editorializing. As we've seen with A/B tested headlines, there is no way to escape this.

> Surely Silicon Valley's politics are nowhere near Marxist or anarchist.

Replace Marxist "bourgeoisie" rhetoric with "white males" and you have the ideology of Silicon Valley.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com