So - what if the hosting company decides to hand over the data because the higherups are very patriotic and find it distasteful that anyone would disrupt the presidential inauguration? There is no law that prevents it, same as that there's no law against refusing to host neonazi websites.

Why did we cheer when the skinheads lost their domain and webhost, and why do we support the other hosting company in keeping their data away from the government? In both cases it's private companies making their own laws, and that is really worrying. When it comes to it, money will support only itself, and there won't be public oversight.