Hacker News Reader

As a layman, you do not have the training to reliably talk to police in a way that best protects your interests. The absolute right to remain silent means that you never have to weigh the need to speak immediately against having the benefit of an attorney's advice.

View on HN

Well if you explain that (very reasonable argument) to the jury at your trial I'm sure they'll be understanding. In practice it would be interesting to know how many suspects are formally interviewed before a lawyer is present. Anecdotally I would think it's low, but I don't know.

I'd be shocked if police don't try to question every single arrested person before they've spoken to a lawyer. It is the best chance the police have to conduct an effective interrogation. You'd be surprised at the number of people who talk their way into prison. There's a reason why the most important legal advice is "ask for a lawyer and shut up".

Scotland, part of the UK, complete right to silence and police aren't allowed to interview you without a solicitor (lawyer) present; unless you specifically decline one.

Overall though the UK is better than the US. You only have to watch a couple of episodes of John Oliver to know that!

Reply on news.ycombinator.com