> SoundCloud could easily exist just by asking artists that want to host more than 5 songs a fee.
They do that. If you want to hsot mroe than a few hours of music and additional stats you need to pay $10 month. I happily do that and it's a perfectly reasonable business model in my opinion.
The problems, as you explained, started when Soundcloud tried to become a general and major label streaming service. A rather bad one compared to Spotify & Co.
It's downright silly to go after such a crowded market when you have rather little to offer.
My guess is that there are more than enough artists, labels and users who actually want to pay and use the service to deliver music to their audience and that this was a profitable niche Soundcloud occupied, but the chase for growth made them lose focus.