Hacker News Reader

Comment by dyim | Hacker News Reader

I thought the aside about NUMMI was interesting [1]. Though the difference between Dayton culture and Chinese culture might be bigger than the difference between Fremont culture and Japanese culture, it's been done successfully before.

[1] https://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/561/..., https://hbr.org/2009/09/nummi-what-toyota-learned, https://consumercal.org/toyatanummi-blue-ribbon-commission-w...

View on HN

Having lived in both Dayton and the bay area for many years, the cultural differences in those places are fewer than many in either place would likely assume. This is probably especially true of those most likely to work in production at one of these two plants.

The differences between any two Americans are going to be much smaller than the differences between two Chinese people from different regions of China, or two Indians from different regions of India. We often take for granted that Native born Americans are drastically more united culturally than people living in more conflict ridden parts of the world.

I think you must have a pretty narrow view of "Americans" if you believe that. Do you think a Shanghaier and a Beijiger have less in common than an Ethiopian refugee in Virginia does with a Hmong in Missouri?

If this is a criticism (not sure what it is actually), is it really fair to criticize any nation for the diversity of its immigrants?

Urban Missouri and urban Virginia are essentially identical culturally, and the rural areas of each state are very similar. I haven't been an immigrant from abroad in either state, but I'd expect the experiences of those once arrived in USA to be fairly similar as well.

Similar in some ways, different in many others. In either case, it's really not accurate to write off the level of diversity in the USA. TV and media give you a very skewed and artificial idea of uniformity in America.

It's not necessary to compare immigrants. You could pick a white guy from rural Appalachia and a white guy from downtown New York and they would be unlikely to have anything in common except that they are both Americans.

They don't need to be immigrants. You can go with second generation families too.

I think you have a very wide view of "Americans".

Or maybe just a non-racist one.

Word, thanks for the input!

Reply on news.ycombinator.com