Why is it the hip and cool thing to call the entire project a train wreck without any actual supporting evidence?

Half the subreddit seems to be die hard acolytes while the other half seem to be extremely bitter vets of a game that hasn't been launched.

The biggest game development project ever, with extraordinary transparency, and shoddy bloggers are still making money throwing out talking points about how it's a train wreck barely half way through development.

Again: without any actual proof. However, if there is any, I will gladly change my opinion.