This argument reminds me of the "you are holding it wrong" excuse by Steve Jobs concerning the reception issues with the iPhone 4:
> https://www.engadget.com/2010/06/24/apple-responds-over-ipho...
At home I use an original model M and I'm quite happy with it and frankly it just isn't that noisy. If people don't like the noise, the problem is they're packed in too closely; perhaps my loud breathing also offends them if they're that deeply invading my personal space.
https://medium.com/@housecor/why-i-stopped-using-multiple-mo...
The limited screen real estate made it really easy to stay focused on my work and not get distracted by HN and Reddit. :)
Personally I find great to have a full screen editor/ide without floating file list and symbols one one monitor and documentation/shell on the second. When you look at one you are not interested in the other so I would not call it multitasking but easier process switching.
People who keep the mail client open should try notifications: events versus polling is much more efficient for low clock human beings.