MobX is really cool, and I wouldn't try to convince anybody not to use it if it works for them. I happen to be pretty religious about immutable data, having been bitten by problems with shared mutable state so many times. I know MobX has actions which help a lot, but I still like the core simplicity of Redux, even if it means more typing.

My dream would be to have David Nolen (of ClojureScript) and Michel Weststrate (of MobX) do a panel where they discuss the essential differences and pros and cons of each approach. The philosophies seem at odds, but I think there's probably a core truth that neither side has fully reached.

Also, I think the core lacking thing of Redux is that it isn't really composable like React. I'm really curious to check out https://github.com/FormidableLabs/freactal since it aims to be a fractal (composable) alternative.

(And yes, props to Elm for having a built-in composable architecture.)