Even more crazy, the James-Stein Estimator which does this actually uses data about the football player and soccer player to make predictions about the baseball player, (and vice-versa). This is deeply unintuitive to most people since the players aren't related to each other at all. The phenomenon only holds with at least three players; it doesn't work for two.
(More generally, Stein's Paradox is the fact that if you have p >= 3 independent Gaussians with a known variance, you can do better in estimating their p-dimensional mean than just using their sample means).
I've spent a bunch of time trying to understand why this actually works [2]; to be honest I still don't deeply understand. But nonetheless the consensus is that the same shrinkage phenomenon is what causes improved performance for a variety of high-dimensional estimators, (lasso or ridge regression, e.g.), making the paradox very very influential.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James%E2%80%93Stein_estimator [2] https://www.naftaliharris.com/blog/steinviz/