Caffeine definitely exacerbated my problem. But quitting caffeine alone was not enough. Avoiding screens (and using f.lux), making my bed a 'sacred space' where only sex and sleep happen (although I still read fiction in it because it helps me nod off), using a red light, and a few other things have also been necessary and even then I sometimes have trouble sleeping.
My kid is experiencing much the same problems and she is not allowed to have caffeine. I'm trying to teach her good sleep hygiene, but the things she's describing and the things I see are very very similar to the things I went through as a teen and sometimes still struggle with.
It may or may not be a coincidence that we trace a significant portion of our ancestry back to places of high latitude. In fact, now I'm kind of curious to ask some of my distance cousins if they've had any of the same issues.
However, I gave up and reverted back to my night-owl ways because it's just not fun going to bed early. Not enough time after working out. And working out in the morning only makes my mornings 3 times more hectic and I hate that.
So it worked for you. Maybe it doesn't work for everyone else.
For me, I switched from being a night owl to a morning person when I kicked my caffeine habit of 1-2 cups per day.
Took a week to get used to waking up early, but now it's nice to collapse in bed around 11pm dead tired instead of just wishing I was tired.
Do you apply such stringent requirements to every single comment you make? Because otherwise it is incredibly hypocritical in the "do as I say not as I do" sense.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delayed_sleep_phase_disorder#M... seems to suggest that in extreme cases at least some of this is, in fact, genetic: it runs in families and there's a specific gene it's thought to be related to.
Edit: own stupidity.
Try waiting until about 2pm or 3pm when your lunch has properly settled. Then find a comfy chair and change into your slippers. You should have no problems nodding off. ;)