As we all know, Amit's real friends called him Mike #2.
Even if everything else fits, this doesn't. And you're messing with someone's life.
(I'm not defending Amit. I don't know him. The claims here strike me as plausible, though I don't know either way. There's a reason such matters are referred to legal systems, ultimately, if necessary. Not a perfect system either, but rather better than unsubstantiated, or worse, glibly false, claims in online media.)