Hacker News Reader

Comment by Florin_Andrei | Hacker News Reader

Yeah, I'm using Sam's TF wheel on RPi3 and it works great.

> it was not feasible to analyze every image captured image from the PiCamera using TensorFlow, due to overheating of the Raspberry Pi when 100% of the CPU was being utilized

Just put a heatsink on the CPU. It's like $1.50 ... $1.95 on Adafruit. I glue a heatsink to every RPi3 unit I build.

https://www.adafruit.com/products/3082

https://www.adafruit.com/products/3083

> it was taking too long to load the 85 MB model into memory, therefore I needed to load the classifier graph to memory

Yeah, one of the first things you learn with TF on the RPi is to daemonize it, load everything you can initially, and then just process everything in a loop. That initialization is super-slow, but after that it's fast enough. YMMV

View on HN

Hi Florin, thanks for the comment!

Even with the heatsink (which we install on all of the Pis), we were still having overheating issues. We tried a few other things too to mitigate the problem: 1. Reducing sampling rate for the image recognition (but if we reduced this beneath several seconds we could miss the express trains) 2. Using a cooling fan (https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B013E1OW4G/ref=oh_aui_sear...) - still didn't prevent overheating if the CPU was continuously loaded at 100%. 3. Only sampling images where we detected motion (https://svds.com/streaming-video-analysis-python/)

We decided to use the 3rd option: Leveraging our motion detection algorithm, which while sensitive to false positives, allows us to use Deep Learning image recognition to eliminate those false positives.

Happy to chat more about your experiences daemonize-ing TF applications!

When you say "overheating issues", what do you mean exactly? IME, at 100% CPU usage with the heatsink on, either it does not throttle down the clock anymore at all, or it does it after a much longer time and the clock reduction is much less.

Are you seeing anything happen, other than some slight throttling?

The chip cannot fry itself. It's designed to slow down so as to stay below the dangerous temperature range.

> Happy to chat more about your experiences daemonize-ing TF applications!

Eh, that was just a fancy way of saying I do what you do. Launch the program once, and let it run forever. It performs initialization (which takes a long time), then it drops into a processing loop: wait for input / read / process / do something / repeat. Pretty basic stuff really.

"Just put a heatsink on the CPU."

Ever had any problems without it?

The cpu throttles when it gets too hot. Won't cause damage to not have it, but will slow it down.

Right, that chip could never run at 100% CPU load for more than a fraction of a minute; after that it starts slowing the clock. Seems to me like it was meant to run with a heatsink on.

Either that or it was meant for outdoors operation in arctic regions.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com