Hacker News Reader

I have little doubt that git will be replaced eventually (or perhaps severely modified). It seems like a fad to me. It is indeed very powerful, but its UI is sheer insanity. At least SVN is very straightforward to use and understand. It just doesn't offer the distributed nature that git does, as it relies on a centralized server.

View on HN

The cool thing about Git is that the underpinnings ultimately boil down to a key-value data store.

I'm not an expert on these innerworkings, but in theory there's nothing stopping someone from creating a new UI that maintains most or all of the same strengths, except that everyone already uses and is used to the current way.

I suspect if you came out with "SuperVCS" that was ultimately just a new UI on Git you'd have more success than releasing the exact same project as some kind of Git enhancement.

Isn't that basically Gitless? (http://gitless.com/)

What UI? Using git on the command line is exactly the same as using SVN on the command line. At least for basic, every day things like status, add, commit etc.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com