Question: In the last few years, how many such online petitions have resulted in some positive, effective action?
There is at least one country that allows petitions to force a referendum on any law. Switzerland.
Naturally such a system develops to a consensus democracy. The reason beeing that a group that is big enough can force a referendum on any law that is passed. So the laws that are passed are usually some sort of consensus.
Implicit in a march at the capital is "This many people could be here with torches and guns". By contrast, people clicking online aren't very active.
No idea on how many did not succeed.