Hacker News Reader

I agree pumped hydro is good, but there are only so many places you can site it.

> Which is why hydrocarbons produce less CO2 per watt than coal.

No. It has nothing to do with water. Coal is a hydrocarbon as well. It has to do with the type of hydrocarbon chains.

Anthracite coal is up to 85.7% carbon by weight the rest is not pure hydrogen but a mix of sulfur, oxygen, nitrogen, and hydrogen. (And yes, that Oxygen lowers the energy density while increasing CO2 release.)

Natural gas is 25% hydrogen 75% carbon.

Burning hydrogen produces water not CO2.

So, while the specific bonds play a role the actual carbon vs. hydrogen content is a major issue.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com