Hacker News Reader

Comment by pmoriarty | Hacker News Reader

Why would it take over as my provider? Aren't there any safety measures to guard against that?

2G networks have basically one way auth. The phone auths to the network but the network doesn't auth to the phone. This is an oversimplification but basically how it works.

Correct. Authentication of the network was added in UMTS/3G.

Nope, none at all. That's how law enforcement like it.

This is not entirely true. LTE is authenticated. If you force your device to not allow any base station using an older protocol (to prevent downgrade attacks), you should be fairly safe. The problem is that most phones will accept a base station that says "No, sorry, can't do LTE, how about this unauthenticated 2G AP instead?" If you are ok with your phone not having network in rural areas, setting it to LTE-only is a reasonable mitigation (assuming your device supports this).

Unfortunately, I don't believe iOS allows selecting the protocol. Android certainly can.

Just checked and iPhone does not seem to have LTE only option.

Are you saying that companies are required to enable this by default?

Some of the other comments are that a 2G tower tells a phone whether it's allowed on or not, but that the phone doesn't have any verification in the other direction. That's just the design of 2G cell networks. It's not an optional setting.

Other comments say that LTE networks authenticate in both directions, so you're safe if you can set your phone to LTE-only.

It's not taking over, rather your phone selects the strongest network subject to partner roaming agreements.

Doors it follow that everyone wandering into that radius for the same text?

Not really, GSM basically connects to the strongest signal with the right codes.

This is a good DefCon talk about how to spoof carrier networks:

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=xKihq1fClQg

Reply on news.ycombinator.com