I'm not even a "foodie" person and the idea of just eating these meal replacements all the time seems like being in "food prison."
I'd call a steady diet of fast food a 'food prison'. That's the addictive stuff that ruins your health.
The reality is you should probably choose neither.
If you want to have a healthy body you have to put it under a stress level for which it was designed by evolution. I.e. exercise once in a while and don't just sit in front of your computer, eat enough fibres and harder to digest food, etc