Hacker News Reader

Why is that hard to believe? The USA created Al Qaeda in our first foray into Afghanistan; they're literally blowback from training mujahedin to fight the Soviets.

View on HN

Even if the USA helped create Al Qaeda (rather controversial) I still find it hard to believe that anyone in the USA thinks it is a good idea to support them today.

In what way is "they're literally blowback from training mujahedin to fight the Soviets." controversial? I'd love to hear this...

this is a dishonest portrayal of events. the arab fighters in afghanistan were not supported by the US and were an extremely marginal presence to begin with. you could make a case for elements of the taliban having links to US support years prior to its establishment, but not AQ affiliates.

the arab fighters in afghanistan were not supported by the US and were an extremely marginal presence to begin with.

You mean, until we sent the CIA in to train them, fund them, and arm them with Stinger missiles?

we did not train, fund or arm the arab fighters. we trained, funded and armed local afghan mujahideen.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com