Hacker News Reader

Comment by gwbas1c | Hacker News Reader

Yesterday, I sat in an exit row on a plane. I remember looking at my bag at my feet and deciding to grab it in an emergency so that other people won't trip on it on their way out.

View on HN

If it's stowed properly under the seat ahead of you, it's not in the way. If it's not stowed properly, then you're already breaking the rules.

Most airlines I have taken even forbid you from stowing bags under the seat if you're sitting on the emergency exit row. Only in the overhead compartments.

I counter your anecdata with my own: unless you're at the front of coach, behind first class, I've never heard of this. I book exit row seats as often as I can.

It is mandatory in EU.

It's not the case in the US if there is a seat in front of you--only in the case of bulkhead seats (whether or not they're an exit row).

Thanks; figured it was probably region-specific. U. S. is where my perspective is coming from.

Some airlines even ban high heels at exit row. And person sitting next to emergency door must be a male, to manage to open it.

I can confirm at least Air France forbids you if you’re on the exit row.

I believe that in the US it is only forbidden during take off and landing.

It's a laptop backpack with straps that can move around a bit. All it takes is someone to hook a toe on a loop, and then that person would go headfirst down the slide.

One of the first things crew does after emergency is to make sure that the exit rows are clear. If your bag does move around during the crash landing and blocks exit, it will be removed out of the way

The point still stands - if it can be tripped over you are not stowing it properly and it should be in the overheads.

Great, so now they can trip over the guy blocking the exit of a burning plane while he struggles to get his overstuffed laptop bag out from under the seat.

Don't do this. Stuff it under the seat like your supposed to do and no one's going to trip.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com