Hacker News Reader

This already went wrong. We are commenting on an older article. He actually got a chance to try this project and it failed pretty resoundingly.

I eagerly await your "no true Scotsman" response.

View on HN

No, he didn't. Honduras cancelled the project.

Failing to coalesce and maintain political support from the host government is just about the most predictable failure mode imaginable.... no true scotsman, indeed.

Ah yes, and there it is.

"The problem with [obviously unworkable governing system] is of course that it's never been given a proper chance!"

So basically, any project which politics cancels can then be assumed to be completely unworkable? Basic income can now be rejected since the Swiss considered it then rejected it? Ok.

Incidentally charter city like policies have been tried. Hong Kong. Singapore. Gurgaon. But I guess all the successes should be ignored because Honduras cancelled their project.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com