My favorite is "Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius".
Still makes me smile to read it.
A kind of analogous later Wikipedia edit war had to do with whether the article about Gadsby (the lipographic novel that doesn't use the letter E) should be written with the same constraint as the novel itself, and also whether the article on E-Prime (an approach to writing English without using the verb "to be") should be written in E-Prime or not. But I feel like the Tlön issue was the granddaddy of all of these controversies.
The one that has stuck with me is "The Immortal"