Hacker News Reader

Comment by neilc | Hacker News Reader

No, more like:

1. Don't treat "Mac fans" as a homogeneous group, and don't attribute some random opinion to them 3 years ago, observe that one particular Mac fan has a different opinion now, and accuse "Mac fans" in general of hypocrisy. That makes no sense.

2. Don't equate "a cheap Dell laptop that does everything you need" with a MacBook Air. That is like comparing apples and oranges.

View on HN

Even if you consider this mac fanboyism, I must say the air is simply a feat of design and engineering. Its hard to deny that. And the price, while being expensive because it is Apple hardware, is sill fairly reasonable. Its not mac fanboyism to praise something that is genuinely aesthetically pleasing.

I do however, wish that I could in fact afford one. Which, I can't.

I was a pretty skeptical regarding the Air. But, just today I went down to the CambridgeSide Apple Store and played with one of them. Its really quite nifty. The weight and thickness are really astounding. The numbers don't really mean much to me... having felt it now though, I can understand why some people love it.

I've had a 2 pounds laptop from Dell for two years now. Apple is a bit late.

With multi touch and backlit keyboard?

No - never missed those, though. The MBA is probably better than my Dell, but that's to be expected with 2 years of technological progress under it's belt.

Although for me personally, my Dell has the ultimate feature: it's fanless. I have raved about that too often on news.yc already, but still...

Downmod me because I'm stating a fact? Jesus there are some bitter individuals out there.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com