Hacker News Reader

I'm not saying the experiments were trustworthy or conducted properly. Only that the author of the article misunderstood the experimental setup.

(To be precise, the comment about the null thruster was made by the author in a comment on this article, and by a previous article written by the author, which this one references. It is not in the article itself.)

View on HN

I realize that, but I'm suggesting that you may have misunderstood the author.

It sounds like you think the author is asserting that the null test article was intended as an experimental control and that its production of thrust is evidence for the null hypothesis.

I read him/her as asserting that the null test article is an experimental apparatus calibration tool, and that the reading of thrust suggests the apparatus is improperly calibrated, so that no results at all can be inferred from the experiment.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com