Hacker News Reader

`goto` to arbitrary labels can be pretty risky. But `goto` to facilitate a single-point-of-exit for a function is a pretty sane idiom. It's all over the linux kernel and I don't think that anyone regrets it.

So I wouldn't state something like "Even Linus isn't perfect," rather "you should be open minded to learn new development idioms in environments where you're less experienced."

View on HN

Check out the function it's from, it's a classic function with multiple guard exits and normal return at the end. The gotos to a label in an if block is what's amusing. But you can see why he's doing that, he has exactly one exit per returned error type.

Agree with you. My first job out of college was working with C code on embedded modem software and when I saw this pattern and was like WTF?! but then realized how useful it is to have single point of exit in a function (especially in embedded systems code).

Often it's very useful to have separate returns from functions for errors. The reason being you can set a break point on the error return and then let the code run. The code will run normally until the error occurs, which in some cases may take days.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com