Hacker News Reader

Comment by edent | Hacker News Reader

Well, I don't consider £50 (US$70, €65) to be particularly cheap. They're certainly more expensive than some of the competition (http://www.wifiplug.co.uk/wifiplug-glass.html).

If you can find me a more expensive and/or higher quality switch - I'll gladly buy and review it.

View on HN

"Inexpensive" and "cheap" are not synonymous. I've experienced plenty of cheap things with a high price, and it produces the perception that the entire industry is terrible.

I've never seen a thesaurus that agrees with you.

The OS X Dictionary app's thesaurus lists "poor-quality" and "low-grade" and "shoddy" as synonyms of cheap. Merriam Webster's online dictionary gives this for definition 3a of cheap:

"of inferior quality or worth"

http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/cheap

Both of the sources you cite list "inexpensive" as a synonym of "cheap", and vice versa.

In fact, I've just looked at the OSX app, and "CHEAP" is the first word after the context in the "inexpensive" entry, and "INEXPENSIVE" is the first word after the context in the "cheap" entry.

http://www.merriam-webster.com/thesaurus/inexpensive http://www.merriam-webster.com/thesaurus/cheap

Yes, in some contexts, they're synonymous. However, they tend to have different connotations. Inexpensive usually implies low in cost, but of reasonable quality. Cheap tends to imply low in cost, and low quality. For example, someone cheaping out on a part.

Yes, but apart from the case of a low quality and cost item ending up more expensive in the long run because of replacements and high maintenance costs; it doesn't tend to mean high in cost,low in quality.

The relationship between the words,in the sense you describe, is hypo/hypernymy.

My original comment was in response to an apparent claim that the two words are entirely unrelated.

Things can indeed be both cheap and expensive. It takes two different perspectives, both being correct in their own right, and not directly contradicting each other.

There can be different ways of looking at the cost of an item: 1) The cost of the parts and manufacture. 2) The retail price.

An item could be cheap from perspective 1 and expensive from perspective 2.

He/she is talking about cheap (quality) vs. inexpensive (cost) - to put it another way, poor-quality items can be expensive.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com