These are two different effects of the same quality.
"Average" means undistinguished, interchangeable; depending on the distribution and context it may mean, with examples:
* normal distribution (IQ): "worse than half of the others"
* distribution with a long positive tail (wealth): "way worse than the best"
* distribution with a compressed left tail (IQ in college-educated adults): "amongst of the worst"
* 20/80 cut-off (female mating strategy): "swipe left"
"Average" also means safe, solid, ideal, normal. This happens when avoiding risk:
* probabilistic estimate of future risk (there is evidence that averaging multiple faces renders a face more beautiful than the rest): average mate => higher probability of average (viable) offspring
* 80/20 cut-off (male mating strategy): "gentlemen prefer blondes — but marry brunettes"
* [too tired to think of other meanings]
Often the same product is both average-good and average-bad, and this is why we have Internet flame wars!