Hacker News Reader

As someone who strongly supports marriage equality and read the full opinion when it came out, I was kinda dismayed to find the dissent a more convincing argument. Did anyone else experience this?

View on HN

No, "good outcome, bad reasoning" is a pretty common opinion about Obergefell.

Did you mean "Yes"? Otherwise I can't understand what you're trying to say.

Sorry, yes, I meant "yes".

Are you one of those people who says "no, yeah, I mean, yeah" or "yeah, no, I mean, no" a lot? I am.

No, that's pretty common, and I am, yeah.

I rarely (I would say never but that would make me a fool) agreed with the man but his dissents were usually well written, worth reading and understanding. For better or worse, he represented the view point of many in America.

Intelligence is no excuse for harm. And Scalia harmed many, in a multitude of ways, over decades in the court, through his plausible misconstrual of the constitution and the law.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com