Hacker News Reader

Comment by anilgulecha | Hacker News Reader

I'd also like to note that TRAI has usually been on the side of user's and not usually caved into lobbying. Over the years they've made sure of:

* Free incoming calls

* state-level number portability so you can switch carriers and hang on to the old number

* national level number portability

* compensation to callers for dropped calls -- an incentive for telecoms to uphold a certain level of service quality

* and now, a stern reply to FB's misleading campaign on free basics.

India as a result has very healthy competition in the telecom space, and the lowest rates in the world.

Kudos, TRAI.

View on HN

> I'd also like to note that TRAI has usually been on the side of user's

What about when it goes against users ? Even now, it has gone against some users. Why do you think its a good thing for <1000 people (TRAI) to affect 1.25 billion ?

The goverment intervention was absolutely unnecessary. They should have left it to market to judge.

common, it is not even a decision. it is merely a remark that TRAI has observed the misleading campaign by fb.

//The goverment intervention was absolutely unnecessary. They should have left it to market to judge. // Regulation is necessary, we cannot let the giants pollute the open internet

> The goverment intervention was absolutely unnecessary. They should have left it to market to judge.

Because that's what I want. Multi-national tech companies going around the world raping economies because "we'll let the market judge".

I'll take regulators please. Slower progress is better sliding backwards.

What if I dont want the regulation as a citizen ? What then ? There are so many issues, so many opinions in the world today. I bet diversity of opinions has never been highest. How should we move as a democracy when everyone has different direction in mind ? Free market is the only solution I can think of.

I acknowledge that not everyone can think/worry about everything. Hence why there would be always need of regulatory/look-out-for-me authorities. However, in this fast paced and diverse world, I propose that they should be opt-in/opt-out.

> What if I dont want the regulation as a citizen ?

You move.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com