Hacker News Reader

HNHacker News

Top New Best Ask Show Jobs

Comment by mfincham | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

mfincham·

I've said it before but I'll say it again:

http://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt

Good checklist of things a potential "reformed SMTP" needs to do.

View on HN

That's quite the low effort response. You could've at least mentioned a point or two that applies to this situation. The list you linked to is not a check list, it only lists ways to shoot ideas down. Although I don't necessarily disagree with the skepticism in this case, consider for a second that a very similar list could have been written up until right before the Wright brothers took off with their plane, supposedly proving manned flight impossible.

Manned flight was a new technology. The proposal to build a new SMTP with [...] requires abandoning SMTP as it is now and convincing everyone to switch.

If the Wright Brothers wanted to eliminate auto accidents by flying, anyone at the time could have told them they were doomed to failure, and history would have proven them right, even though air travel is safer than road travel. That's because getting people to stop using cars isn't simply a matter of inventing an airplane.

a very similar list could have been written up until right before the Wright brothers took off with their plane, supposedly proving manned flight impossible

Someone should write up such a list along with a bot that replies to any post that cites the craphound link linked above. I think it's a valid counterpoint.

Nevertheless, whenever someone offers up a cure-all for SMTP, that craphound list is the first thing that comes to mind.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com