So, just to be clear here, the refutation to Piketty was published in the Journal of Private Enterprise by a policy professor from George Mason University and another author from the Institute for Energy Research?

Or in other words, it was published in the Libertarian Journal of Libertarianism by a libertarian academic and a libertarian think-tanker at a libertarian think-tank, funded by the Koch Brothers[1]?

This really doesn't pass the smell test.

[1] -- http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Institute_for_Energy_Re...