Hacker News Reader

I believe I have the right to gather a group and attack, say, a coal fired power plant that is lowering the quality of my air.

Each and every employee and shareholder of that plant is assaulting me and I thus have a right to shoot them on sight.

For this reason, a true free market would actually have almost no fossil fuel emissions.

View on HN

You can believe whatever you want, but most systems of justice recognize things like proportionality and imminence.

While a nearby coal power plant is likely to harm your health, it's unlikely to kill you, so killing someone over it would be disproportional.

Also, even if it were going to kill you, it's not going to kill you right now, so shooting on sight instead of exhausting other avenues would be avoidable and hence not self-defense or justifiable.

Most people would sympathize with you as a victim of this coal plant, but find you guilty of a crime.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com