HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wintermutestwin

2,471 karma · joined March 27, 2020

contact me: wintermutetwin at the omniscient goog.
submissionscomments
wintermutestwin··on To AI or not to AI
I pasted the results of typing man rsync into my macbook’s terminal. I looked up the —delete parameter and pasted the entry. Not sure why your entry was more useful - perhaps a version issue (which is at the root of the painful time I have spent trying to learn how to do something trivial).

Later in the man page, it gives examples and totally fails to explain those examples. And yes, for someone who is going to be doing this frequently and professionally. They should understand this deeply and spending the hours required to be fluent in a command with a kitchen sink full of parameters. I, on the other hand, will be executing these commands maybe a few times in a year.

The more I think about it, the more I think the solution here is to use LLM‘s to write better documentation with lenses for different types of users with different needs.

wintermutestwin··on Kagi News
I am sticking with this reprehensible company for email because their spam detection is awesome and I have found no clear measurements of detection to reasonably compare. I’d love to be proven wrong!
wintermutestwin··on To AI or not to AI
>rsync which is well documented

Here is the man page entry for the --delete flag:

--delete is used. This option is mutually exclusive with --delete-during, --delete-delay, and --delete-after.

Hilarious!

Reading and understanding the rsync command would take much more than 10 mins and I am not a total newb here.

wintermutestwin··on To AI or not to AI
Bah! Coders need to learn to write documentation. The tldr for rsync was hilarious! Actually, this is one place where LLMs are currently useful! Instead of getting LLMs to write code, get it to write documentation.
wintermutestwin··on To AI or not to AI
The “fucking” manual is obtuse, overly verbose, and almost always lacking in super clear real world examples. That you claim it is a <10 min problem demonstrates experts disregard for the degree of arcane crap, a beginner needs to synthesize.

I am backing up and verifying critical data here. This is not a task that should be taken lightly. And as I learned, it is not a task that one can rely on an LLM for.

wintermutestwin··on To AI or not to AI
I am on a $20 plan and using the "thinking" version of 5.
wintermutestwin··on To AI or not to AI
So I paste the man page into llm and tell it to only give me parameters that are in that page? Even if it obeyed, it would still choke on how to exclude hidden MacOS kruft files from the copy...
wintermutestwin··on To AI or not to AI
tldr pages are a great idea, but the execution is a total fail. Looking at the rsync entry, it fails to provide the most blatantly common requirements:

I just needed two commands: one to mirror a folder from one drive to another, updating only the changes (excluding all of the hidden MacOS cruft). And another command to do a deep validation of the copy. These have to be two of the most commonly used commands right???

In the end, I felt that messing around with precious data without being 100% certain of what I am doing just wasn't worth it so I got a GUI app that was intuitive.

wintermutestwin··on To AI or not to AI
Lots of reasons! First off: where else do I go to learn this stuff? Man pages are reference for people who work in CLI all the time and not for virgin learners as they are are necessarily packed with the complete lexicon but with barely a thought to explaining real world examples of common tasks. There are a million Linux websites with the same versioning issues and inadequate explanations. I guess I could buy an oreily book and learn the topic end to end even though I will only need to know the syntax of a couple commands.

With an LLM, I can get it to tell me what each parameter it suggests actually does and then I can ask it questions about that to further my understanding. That is a massive leg up over the knowledge spaghetti approach...

wintermutestwin··on To AI or not to AI
I recently spent over an hour trying to get ChatGPT to give me some pretty simple rsync commands. It kept giving me command line parameters that didn't work on the version of rsync on my mac. With ~50% of the failures, it would go down troubleshooting rabbit holes and the rest of the time it would "realize" that it was giving incorrect version responses. I tell it to validate each parameter against my version moving forward and it clearly doesn't do that. I am sure I could have figured it out on my own in 5 mins, but I couldn't stop watching the trainwreck of this zeitgeist tech wasting my time doing a simple task.

I am not a coder (much), but I have to wonder if my experience is common in the coding world? I guess if you are writing code against the version that was the bulk of its training then you wouldn't face this specific issue. Maybe there are ways to avoid this (and others) pitfall with prompting? As it is, I do not see at all how LLMs could really save time on programming tasks without also costing more time dealing with its quirks.

wintermutestwin··on Yt-dlp: Upcoming new requirements for YouTube downloads
I agree and feel that the time is now to archive all of the truly valuable cultural and educational content that YT acquired through monopolistic means.

This solution looks interesting, but I am technical enough to know that this looks like a PITA to setup and maintain. It also seems like it is focused on downloading everything from a subbed channel.

As it is now, with a folder of downloaded videos, I just need a local web server that can interpret the video names and create an organized page with links. Is there anything like this that is very lightweight with a next next finish install?

wintermutestwin··on Bitwig Studio 6 details revealed, and editing gets a big boost
Don’t you use reference tracks? I assume that anyone seriously using a DAW does. Imagine being able to easily reference just one instrument.

Just to call out a pretty universal use case for stem separation…

wintermutestwin··on Bitwig Studio 6 details revealed, and editing gets a big boost
>There’s something refreshing about v6. No AI or stem separation.

Stem separation in Logic is an insanely useful feature.

wintermutestwin··on Claude Opus 4.1
Yes. You basically need an LLM to provide guidance on product selection in this brave new world.

It is actually one of my most useful use cases of this tech. Nice to have a way to ask in private so you don’t get snarky answers like: it’s just like buying shoes!

wintermutestwin··on Offline.kids – Screen-free activities for kids
Can we please stop using “screens” as a pejorative?

There are plenty of examples where a screen provides a better and more enriching/edifying experience than dead trees, etc

wintermutestwin··on The Convenience Trap: Why Seamless Banking Access Can Turn 2FA into 1FA
> something you have (phone) and something you are (face), OR something you have (phone) and something you know (passcode).

Thank you for breaking it down like this. The bottom line is that if you don’t have your phone, you can’t access your accounts. That is a massive risk factor - particularly while traveling. That tells me that passkeys and password managers are not a viable security solution.

wintermutestwin··on Copyparty – Turn almost any device into a file server
?? Airdrop works well.
wintermutestwin··on VPN use surges in UK as new online safety rules kick in
I am surprised that the housing markets in Spain and Portugal haven’t declined due to Brexit.
wintermutestwin··on Facts don't change minds, structure does
Just to add to this: I couldn’t read the text in the white boxes of the graphs. Very unfortunate choices of colors…
wintermutestwin··on What a Hacker Stole from Me
The MyNoise app has tangibly improved my life. I use a white noise machine at home, but when I travel, MyNoise is my sleep companion and I particularly appreciate that I can set the EQ to block the particular noises that are likely to wake me.

Sorry to hear about the annoying hack…

wintermutestwin··on Microsoft extends free Windows 10 security updates into 2026
>On the other hand, for whatever reason Windows 11 right now refuses to install updates (I think the logs complained about their own web view components being unavailable last I checked, which is wrong because they definitely are there), which is kind of embarrassing.

Updates failing and the horrible troubleshooting process is the main reason I’d love to ditch their abortion of an OS. As it is, the most powerful computer of my many is just used for gaming.

wintermutestwin··on The Effect of Noise on Sleep
I will definitely check it out then as I am frustrated by the same problem where Apple shows me as asleep when I am meditating myself back to sleep. It even shows me as sleeping when I have pushed the crown to see the time!
wintermutestwin··on The Effect of Noise on Sleep
What does AutoSleep offer above and beyond Apple’s Health app?

I have (and recommend) a white noise machine at home, but when I travel, I use the awesome MyNoise app, which lets you EQ the noise precisely so you can target the specific annoyance in your environment.

wintermutestwin··on Transparent Ambition: on translucent user interfaces
As someone who has to put on reading glasses to get any information from my apple phone and watch purely due to obnoxious design choices by Apple, I’d say they embody UI failure.
wintermutestwin··on YouTube's new anti-adblock measures
I’d gladly pay for ad free youtube if they weren’t double dipping by stealing my data.
wintermutestwin··on Base44 sells to Wix for $80M cash
As someone who was responsible for setting up brochureware sites that non technical users needed to be able to edit, these site builders were the only option I could find. Taking over a shitty WP site that was built with a hodgepodge of plugins (that were mostly dead) was a nightmare and a different flavor of walled garden.

I went with Wix, as it was the best of the builders, but it is still totally crap. I do not understand why web tech has moved so slowly in this area.

wintermutestwin··on Base44 sells to Wix for $80M cash
I hate this response! Businesses that rely on shitty facebook crap don’t get my business. And hiring someone to make a brochureware website is a maintenance nightmare. Do you work with small businesses much?
wintermutestwin··on Base44 sells to Wix for $80M cash
What??? It is trivially easy to mess up a website in a builder like this. I am reasonably technical and I have to restore many times when making structural edits.
wintermutestwin··on Base44 sells to Wix for $80M cash
>Companies like Squarespace set the bar much higher.

When I was evaluating user friendly web platforms for several non-profits, I ended up choosing Wix over Squarespace because Squarespace didn't provide backup>restore functionality. That's a pretty low bar...

wintermutestwin··on The Unreliability of LLMs and What Lies Ahead
What I don’t understand is, how can a liar be good at data analysis?
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →