vipshek

For what it’s worth, the transcript I posted is 100% of the conversation I had with GPT-4. “How do LEDs work?” was the only thing I wrote in the initial question.

I did try Googling “how do LEDs work” for comparison, but it yielded the same top few results. Of course, I could have iteratively tried different search queries to get to the answers I wanted, but this gets at my real point: I don’t have to formulate 5 different search queries anymore, allowing me to maintain one focused line of inquiry. I talk about this a little in the “fewer browser tabs” bit of the post.

I do think someone could create an alternative search UI that would be better for learning on the web. Something where you can run multiple searches and “collect” the useful information you find into a single page, rather than having the results split across a mess of browser tabs and note-taking windows. Maybe I just find juggling many browser tabs more annoying than other people do?

Anyway, I tried the queries you posted above, and most resources I found were still very confusing for a layman. The one exception is this page, which I think does a great job of introducing additional complexity on this topic gradually: https://electronics.howstuffworks.com/led.htm

OP here. I think learning exists on a broad spectrum. On one end, you're just indulging curiosity ("I wonder how...?"). On the other, you're trying to build deep understanding and expertise.

I completely agree that for the latter goal, the approaches in the blog post are insufficient, even undesirable. And I do worry that the way I engage with content on the web is weakening my ability to go deep on a subject I'm interested in.

But I do think there is value in just being able to indulge curiosity quickly and consistently. Not only is it rewarding in its own right, but it also provides the spark that leads you to eventually go deeper.

Lately, I've found myself sitting at a laptop with friends, asking GPT a question, reading and discussing the response, and then coming up with and asking followup questions as a group. I don't think we would've done that in the past, because the interface of search engines and webpages and browser tabs were too unwieldy to engage with collectively. It just feels like a completely new way to learn things, and what's what I'm most excited about.

Seems like a typo: https://outschool.com/

This strikes me a similar to a dynamic at the level of entire corporations and industries—commodification/modularization on one end, wholeness/integration on the other: https://stratechery.com/2015/netflix-and-the-conservation-of...