HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tptacek

425,412 karma · joined November 1, 2007

Having said thus much by way of introduction, I commit the following to the candour of the Publick.

Helu! I'm Thomas.

thomas@sockpuppet.org

t@tk.inc

(Don't apologize for contacting me! I'm happy to meet you.)

Daily follow list: 'jcranmer, 'rgovostes, 'pvg, 'rgovostes, 'lisper, 'kentonv, 'DannyBee, 'JumpCrisscross, 'kasey_junk, 'tzs, 'dctoedt, 'idlewords, 'carbocation (many others who don't post often enough to call out like this).

All comments Copyright © 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2015, 2018, 2023, 2031 Thomas H. Ptacek, All Rights Reserved.

submissionscomments
tptacek··on Does Georgism work? Five years later
Well, yeah, that's humanity for you.
tptacek··on Does Georgism work? Five years later
This is well studied, and I don't believe that's true: a luxury development _reduces_ rents in the immediate surrounding area.
tptacek··on Does Georgism work? Five years later
I know that not to be true in my area as well.
tptacek··on Does Georgism work? Five years later
Local politics are very different, especially in responsiveness, to state and national politics.
tptacek··on Does Georgism work? Five years later
People say the same things here, where I know them not to be true, but I don’t know anything about your municipality. I know what the social science says about this, and the common sense intuition that never occurs to people to turn out in favor of apartments they’re not going to live in, but does occur to people who want to stop it. Your mileage obviously varies.
tptacek··on Does Georgism work? Five years later
I’ve since learned that overly online keyboard warriors are the least important people to convince. The most important people are on your local city council or state legislature. Furthermore, instead of wasting time with hard cases or elected officials who are dead-set against your ideas, you’re much better off finding and working with people who are already interested in your principles. This often means giving up on your own city or state, at least for the time being, and pursuing a “succeed anywhere” strategy instead.

We're about to have a board vote eliminating single-family zoning (I expect us to win) and this rings extremely true about local politics. If you count "votes" in Facebook comments --- Facebook is where all our local politics happen --- you'd think this is the most contentious issue in the world. But in our last mayoral election, you'd draw the same conclusion about the race being tight, and in fact the progressive rinsed the moderate by a huge margin.

The same thing is very true of public meetings; the turnout for comment at those things is almost never representative of the area's median sentiment. "No" turns out for everything; "yes" rarely does.

I spend a lot of time in online arguments with opponents, on the theory that I'm not really writing to the person I'm arguing with but rather to everyone quietly reading comments. But it's almost certainly the case that the only conversations that have really mattered have been with electeds themselves.

tptacek··on Early rogue AI agent activity and attempts to hack found on urlquery.net
It depends on the statute, but if you're talking about 18 USC 1030, the standard is intentionality (if not to intentionally access something you shouldn't, then intent to defraud).
tptacek··on Plunging test scores are a slow-moving catastrophe
It's not clear to me why you believe those two claims are in opposition.
tptacek··on What even is an OS now?
No, I'm following society's lead on this one. Maybe people won't want this! Then we'll fail. I'll be fine with that.
tptacek··on Reflections on 1,000 Days of Math
OK, as long as you're clear that this is an indictment of basically all ordinary undergraduate math instruction.
tptacek··on Automattic has a new board after failed attempt to put CEO on leave
It's a valid stance for a random individual, but not for a board member, who assumes additional obligations that are external to their own personal morals. If your morality and your board duties conflict, your obligation is to resign.
tptacek··on Automattic has a new board after failed attempt to put CEO on leave
They're specifically not supposed to represent the interests of a minority of the shareholders!

That doesn't mean they're required to faithfully represent the interests of any one person with majority voting power, but it does mean they can't select some random subset of minority voters and serve them instead.

tptacek··on What even is an OS now?
What's your point?
tptacek··on What even is an OS now?
It is not good to make things ordinary people use hard just for the sake of making it hard, or even in the pursuit of a perceived quality threshold if that threshold is beyond what the users will perceive. The cart is extremely dragging the horse in our field.
tptacek··on What even is an OS now?
When you suggest that ordinary people should not use personal applications that they've built with AI because it robs them of the hacker spirit, that's what you're doing: orienting all of society around your aesthetic preference.
tptacek··on What even is an OS now?
Sure they can. Of course they can. "Computers suck" is practically the motto of the entire field of software security. That doesn't mean they're not fun to work with! Just that they suck.
tptacek··on Reflections on 1,000 Days of Math
Oh, I have no idea if it can help make someone a mathematician. But that's not why engineers study math, right? It's still extremely valuable to be able to do, and to an operational extent understand, advanced math.
tptacek··on What even is an OS now?
I have no idea what this analogy is meant to communicate. If you're trying to suggest that software construction is only intentional or attributable if you write source code by hand, I'll just come back and say you haven't legitimately build anything unless you hex-edited it in machine code.
tptacek··on Automattic has a new board after failed attempt to put CEO on leave
That's sort of true and sort of not, right? He's not in fact "the boss" of the board, though with his voting ability (and that of his committed proxies) he can replace the board instantly.

The board has every right to fire the CEO. That's not at issue. The board could reasonably do that even if the CEO has majority voting control --- iff the board is certain the CEO won't immediately reverse the decision and replace the board. If they fire the CEO performatively (or as a hail mary) knowing the CEO will reverse them, they're causing operational chaos with no upside, and that's not something the board can legitimately do.

There's a subtext in some comments about this that the board can legitimately express a position that it's better that the company not exist than exist with Mullenweg at the helm. That's not a legitimate thing for the board to pursue.

tptacek··on What even is an OS now?
I'm not saying it's not important, just that you can't reasonably expect to orient all of society around it. And that's what we're talking about when we talk about how computing is going to work for ordinary people.
tptacek··on What even is an OS now?
I think you just wrote "lots of things are more important than the hacker ethos, like [axiomatic rederivation of the hacker ethos]". That's not a persuasive argument.
tptacek··on What even is an OS now?
This is obviously false.
tptacek··on Reflections on 1,000 Days of Math
Please don't post insinuations about astroturfing, shilling, brigading, foreign agents, and the like. It degrades discussion and is usually mistaken. If you're worried about abuse, email hn@ycombinator.com and we'll look at the data.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

tptacek··on Reflections on 1,000 Days of Math
Isn't this more or less true of the whole undergraduate college calc syllabus? Like, I had the same thought grinding on trig integrals: "these problems seem super artificial", and I gather they basically are, and I guess closed-form solutions to arbitrary random integrals all sort of are? But that's not Math Academy's doing, or any kind of "teach to the test"; I went through these same problems with both my kids as they did STEM degrees at Illinois, and that's the actual material.
tptacek··on Reflections on 1,000 Days of Math
I'm a broken record on how valuable I found Math Academy to be; 22,000 XP in roughly a year, going from high school trig (and a grim confrontation with my intuitive ability to work with fractions) through multivariable calculus.

The most important thing to understand about Math Academy is that it's all problems, problems over and over again, with just enough pedagogy to get you from one kind of problem to the next. It's a form of spaced-repetition system (often with the repetition cleverly arranged through interleaved topics, so that solving problems in the "next" unit also depends on techniques from the previous) and a drilling tool.

I'd echo any other observation about that structure being limiting for deeper understanding. The thing about that is, though, we already have ample resources for deeper understanding! For my part, GPT4 and GPT5 were more than enough supplementation, to drill into topics, connect them to other topics, ask "why the fuck does this work", etc.

When I got to Calc II (in Math Foundations III), Herbert Gross MIT lectures were super handy too. If you're doing Linear Algebra, I'd pair Math Academy with Strang's lectures.

To me, the limitations of the approach aren't interesting. The problem Math Academy is solving is the limiting reagent for self-study: boundless exercises and worked examples, a clear syllabus, and a forcing function for actually doing the problems. If you're self-studying math, you probably don't need extra structure to get you to read about math; you need the structure to get you to do math.

Easily the most valuable learning resource I've ever spent money on. Highly recommend.

tptacek··on What even is an OS now?
It could well be devastating for "the hacker ethos". You can lament that all you want. But there are more important things than "the hacker ethos".
tptacek··on What even is an OS now?
I do not think it's a good thing for normal people to have to learn programming languages to built programs to solve their problems. To me this is like how the HAM radio people used to be required to learn Morse code.

I get that it might suck for people like us, who took the time to learn those languages! Oh well.

tptacek··on Automattic has a new board after failed attempt to put CEO on leave
Minority shareholder rights do not generally include a right to remove officers of the company unilaterally.
tptacek··on Automattic has a new board after failed attempt to put CEO on leave
All you're really saying here is that you wish Mullenweg had lost this power struggle. I get that. I'm not sticking up for Mullenweg. But the adults in the room all knew that Mullenweg wasn't going to lose, and created chaos anyways. You can't pin that on Mullenweg.
tptacek··on Automattic has a new board after failed attempt to put CEO on leave
Wordpress is a private company. This is a normal private-company structure.

I'm not suggesting the board actually did anything legally risky here. The standards for that in Delaware are high. But morally, it's much harder to defend, so long as they knew this is what the outcome would be --- which it seems like they kind of clearly did.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →