HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tmnvdb

426 karma · joined February 15, 2022

submissionscomments
tmnvdb··on Introducing deep research
LLMs often don't do well on tasks that require composition into smaller subtasks. In this case there is a chain of relations that depend on the previous result.
tmnvdb··on Introducing deep research
Yes, they show benchmarks in the article linked here. Did you not read it?
tmnvdb··on Introducing deep research
I would consider unsupervised tool usage an achievement
tmnvdb··on Introducing deep research
HN is full of people who want to feel smart by complaining.
tmnvdb··on Introducing deep research
You're not wrong but it feels like bikeshedding at this point.
tmnvdb··on Introducing deep research
This is a hard question for language models since it targets one of their known weaknesses.
tmnvdb··on Introducing deep research
> At least there was some understanding behind the scenes of where the numbers came from, and sources would/could be provided.

Oh Sweet summer child.

tmnvdb··on Introducing deep research
You can synthesize the parts to get the whole. Both uses are correct AFAIK
tmnvdb··on Introducing deep research
Peak HN comment
tmnvdb··on Introducing deep research
How is using public information "exploitation"? A human researcher with Google would do the same.
tmnvdb··on Introducing deep research
Eating popcorn while the scaling doubters scramble to move the goalposts for the nth time.
tmnvdb··on Introducing deep research
Have you even watched the video? This is a new capability and not a trivial one.
tmnvdb··on Introducing deep research
Do you have any benchmarks to back up your 'feelings'?
tmnvdb··on Introducing deep research
Only if you are asking questions at the level of a cutting edge benchmark
tmnvdb··on OpenAI O3-Mini
That is the biggest problem on this website, people want to feel smart by 'debunking' things they don't really understand. It leads to a lot of contrarian views with poor signal to noise ratio, especially when the topic is slightly outside of average user experience (midwit programming)
tmnvdb··on FBI, Dutch police disrupt 'Manipulaters' phishing gang
The US has different presidents all the time
tmnvdb··on OpenAI O3-Mini
Probably they are doing so well because there are not endless meetings on customer friendly names
tmnvdb··on OpenAI O3-Mini
Those models are not comparable
tmnvdb··on OpenAI O3-Mini
It is not very good though.
tmnvdb··on Italy's privacy regulator goes after DeepSeek
This is such a weird stereotype. The US was declared in 1776. Obviously it has generational wealth. Unless you think everybody lives to be 300 years old.
tmnvdb··on Italy's privacy regulator goes after DeepSeek
With all due respect, your idea of Europe seems to be about a 100 years out of date and based on period dramas.
tmnvdb··on Italy's privacy regulator goes after DeepSeek
This is a bit of a myth, most countries in Europe have better social mobility then the US, where people of different social classes are quite segregated. (Though as always, there is a lot of variation between countries.)
tmnvdb··on Italy's privacy regulator goes after DeepSeek
The country with by far the highest number of people riding a bike (The Netherlands) does not have any helmet rules.
tmnvdb··on Italy's privacy regulator goes after DeepSeek
That is partly true, though not equally so in every country (Denmark is a positive example - as usual). Note that this kind of regulation is done on the national level and isn't strictly related to EU membership.

On the other hand, salaries in the EU are significantly lower and it is a lot easier to find engineers.

Even as a person who dislikes the overregulation it is not totally clear to me that the net status of the labour market is what makes entrepeneurship as impossible as you claim, despite the obvious negative effect of overregulation.

If that was the main problem I would expect a "Silicon Valley" of Europe to form in Denmark or one of the other smaller states that have relatively flexible labour markets, but we are not really seeing that, as they are still hampered by a lack of funding.

Instead we see that the biggest startup hubs are in Berlin and Paris, probably more related to network effects and national (financial) market size then to particularly attractive regulation, for which those places are not known.

tmnvdb··on Italy's privacy regulator goes after DeepSeek
Regulation is only a small part of the story. Keep in mind that GDPR was implemented in 2018, long after Europe lost the tech battle.

The lack of a unified (financial) service sector and hence a very weak and fragmented private capital market (-> VC ecosystem) is a bigger problem. Most funding is from risk-averse banks and slow-moving governments.

Many EU based startups move to silicon valley for access to financing.

tmnvdb··on DeepSeek-R1: Incentivizing Reasoning Capability in LLMs via RL
Did you try asking deepseek about June 4th, 1989? Edit: it seems that basically the whole month of July 1989 is blocked. Any other massacres and genocides the model is happy to discuss.
tmnvdb··on What I've learned about writing AI apps so far
I disagree with several of these, and the whole thing does not seem very well-conceived, based on an "incorrect" notion of what AI "should" do to be considered impressive.

> LLMs only reliably know what you just told them, don't rely on training data

This depends a lot on the model but i've been using 4o for all kinds of information retrieval and found it to be generally reliable. At least not much worse than the general internet. You can ask it for sources and of course you should not use it as an authority, but it can often be a very good way to quickly find out a fact. You do need to developed a feeling for the kind of thing it will know realiably and the kind of thing that will cause it to start halucinating (a bit like some of your co-workers).

> LLMs cannot write for you

I disagree, LLMs can write small blocks of text very well. But there is an art to using it. Don't try to create too much at once. I often find it works better then I give less input. If you list a bunch of things it needs to include, it tends the result reads like a student trying to include all the buzzwords.

> LLMs can help a human perform tasks, they cannot replace a human

I don't think anybody claims otherwise for current public models.

> Have the LLM do as little as possible

You need to learn what LLMs do well, and then use it for that. The idea that it is most efficient to program everything by hand as much as possible does not match my experience. Writing boilerplate code of under 50 lines of code or so is something current models already do very well and very quickly. I usually just try to generate it and if it does not work I write it by hand.

Finally, LLMs now take video and audio. We use Gemini to write meeting notes from Google meet and they tend to be very high quality, a lot better then what a random person taking notes usually produces. So the models are not text-only.

tmnvdb··on Poland fumes over US block on AI chips
Poland is aiming for 4.7% in 2025 and is supporting Trumps proposal for 5% for NATO.

Meanwhile Italy is allowed to buy chips with 1.5% defense spending.

It doesn't make sense to think that defense spending is the criterion used to select the countries.

tmnvdb··on Poland fumes over US block on AI chips
You can just put the datacentre in Germany or the Netherlands and use it in Poland.
tmnvdb··on Poland fumes over US block on AI chips
That argument would make more sense if they did not include Poland, the biggest per capita spender and a staunch US ally.
← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →