HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

timwiseman

2,864 karma · joined May 19, 2009

Timothy A Wiseman is a SQL Server DBA who dabbles in Python.
submissionscomments
timwiseman··on Why I Got Fired: America's Compliance Nightmare
You make an excellent point, in many jobs consistency is valued far above outstanding results and should be. If that is not for you, do not work there.

But, having worked in a couple of call centers, I feel obliged to point out not all of them are that way. I have been in call centers for major products where there were no scripts, the representatives (or "agents") were expected to think and help solve problems for the customers as well as provide feedback to other departments making the products. But I will agree those are a minority and in some call centers they are separated out into "level 2" or something equivalent.

timwiseman··on Google Drive
"The Google drive also seems to be available on all platforms"

Not yet. There is no broad based Linux support yet (it supports Android, which is technically Linux, but no Linux Desktop distro is supported) and iOS support is still in the works.

timwiseman··on Google Drive
I am fully with you. As a general rule, I process text much faster (and more selectively) than I can process a video.

The only time I prefer video is when it is something that truly benefits from being demonstrated in a way that is cumbersome to describe in words. Working with software is almost always best described in words with some pictures, but I found videos extremely helpful in origami.

timwiseman··on Introducing Google Drive... yes, really
At the risk of being pendantic, I don't think there should ever be an only copy of anything remotely important. (and even 1 local + 1 remote controlled by a single 3rd party is probably not a good policy if it is significant)
timwiseman··on Is it OK to Want to Make Money?
Very well said. As long as you do not compromise your ethics in the process, it is probably good to seek money.

Its worth pointing out that one of the best ethical ways to make money is provide people things or services they want at prices they are willing to pay. As long as you are doing that in an ethical way for people that are also generally ethical, you are probably improving the world while earning money for yourself.

timwiseman··on IKamasutra: Apple Hates Brunettes
I agree with you, which is why I use Android. But, I see an appeal to the walled garden.

I can let my children get on the app store without worrying too much it will lead to questions I don't feel like answering at that age. I have greater confidence that getting a game for the kids won't come with overly onerous spyware. I also have a better feeling that it will generally work.

This is not the way I want to operate, but I see how it appeals to some people.

timwiseman··on Why it's OK to leave a tech job at 5 p.m.
The basic idea being discussed is very close to a "Guarunteed Minimum Income" ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guaranteed_minimum_income ). Essentially, everyone regardless of work is supplied with a certain minimum, but with enough work they can earn far more than that minimum.

I do not believe it has ever been fully tried in practice (though a strong social safety net comes somewhat close in a piecemeal fashion). But there is no reason in principle it cannot work and some respected thinkers such as Thomas Paine have advocated it. There would be enough people motivated by a combination of the love of the job and the desire to earn more than the low-guarunteed minimum to ensure necessary societal functioned.

It may have some undesirable side effects, but in principle it could be made to work.

Edit: Slight edit for clarity.

timwiseman··on Parents: Read the damn box
You make good points. As a busy parent, I certainly sympathesize with people that feel like they have too little time to monitor what they're kids are exposed to.

I think one very significant factor is making sure that they can come to you, as a parent, when they come across a new concept. Of course, as you said, I would prefer to introduce the concepts on my timeline, but I also need to be ready to deal with them whent he come up. More than that, I need to make sure my kids feel comfortable coming to me when they come up. Otherwise, it won't be a discussion I need to have "right now", it will be a discussion that happens with other friends that are probably just as confused and unprepared as mine are.

timwiseman··on The Most Dangerous Gamer
I think you may have taken this too far. Graphics and sound can contribute to or detract from fun, but in the end it is fun that keeps people buying a game. A game that looks great, but plays poorly will not survive, but a game that plays fantastically might be around for years later.

I played Planescape Torment many years after it was released because I kept hearing about it. Comparing it to graphics in other games that I played at the time the graphics were poor. But it had a tremendous story and was a lot of fun, so I played it through and still recommend it to others even though it is now even more dated.

timwiseman··on When will I ever use math?
Very well said. Though it is worth noting the distinctions between different types of math.

I found my studies of theoretical math in college enormous fruitful just as I found jogging beneficial. But I thought doing numerous arithmetic problems in middle school to be of minimal value and the rote memorization of things like multiplication tables to be worthless.

In short, much like exercise, studying math should be done in a way that is pushing your personal limits at least a little.

timwiseman··on A Man Can’t Live on Image Credit Alone
I do not think this follows. Linus Torvalds got well-paying work because of his free work on Linux. Of course, Torvalds is an outlier, but Cory Doctorow also does this.

It makes sense that the best way to get work in certain fields is to have a reputation. Sometimes the best way to get that reputation is to give away a certain portion of your work.

timwiseman··on What Americans Buy
Groceries make up a smaller percentage partially because they are so much cheaper than eating out.

As for it being healthier, it all depends on your choices. If I am eating in, but having noodles and microwave pizza it will be much less healthy than getting a salad out. I have been on business trips where I ate every meal at a restauraunt for more than two weeks, but it was a relatively healthy diet.

timwiseman··on What Americans Buy
Perhaps someone could explain this to me, "But too many workers serving a need leads in one direction for prices: Up."

I am no economist, but I would expect the opposite. Having too many people in one field would result in a reduction in wages and prices until people started leaving that field as a result and the supply/demand ratio stabilized. What am I missing or misunderstanding?

timwiseman··on Math For Programmers
Wikipedia is a fantastic resource, but it is first and foremost an Encyclopedia, a reference. It has many times helped me refresh my memory or helped explain something I read first in another context. But it is not a good place to learn a brand new subject.

There are many good resources to learn math, most in the form of books (some of which have digital versions). Personally, I find it best to find a subtopic that interests me and dive in. Though I will say that I would recommend "Chapter Zero" to most people wanting to get back into math after a long break.

timwiseman··on Why I’m taking full responsibility for my education
I partially agree. The onus is always on the indivdual. An organized class can provide comraderie, a place to ask questions, guidance, and many other benefits. But in the end, it is always up to the individual to get something out of it. A determined person with some basic resources can learn without a class, and a person who puts no effort in will not learn in even the best class.

But as for I refuse to believe that there is a student anywhere that really wants to learn but cannot. That is true, but only to a degree. There remain plenty of places, even in America, where internet access is limited and a young student in particular may not have the resources to get consistent and frequent internet access. Similarly, there are places where the libraries are not accessible in a practical way.

A truly determined person, such as Srīnivāsa Rāmānujan can rise above, but they are the exceptions and even Ramanujan got help from people to reach his peak.

timwiseman··on Why I’m taking full responsibility for my education
I just wish people could forget the idea that Math is fun. It is not.

This is anecdotal, but I find at least the math I have learned to be fun. I got a BS in math and took some masters-level classes because I enjoyed it. I still work through recreational mathematics and play with project Euler and fractals when I have time.

You mention higher levels and more abstract forms of math, and I cannot say I would still have found it fun if I pursued a PHD and tried to truly breach new frontiers, but I can say that my professors generally all told me they enjoyed it. They did it because they had fun with it.

Different people find different things fun, but I think its safe to say that some people find even advanced mathematics fun.

timwiseman··on A Woman’s Story
You make an excellent point, but I think it may be dangerous to conflate race and culture. I suspect for instance that a person of Japanese heritage that grew up in the US and spoke only English might have almost as much trouble with the Kanji characters as I would.
timwiseman··on Batman's Real Story
couple million dollar is so minuscule, that you might as well measure the benefit of it in terms of emotional value, instead of any "objective" measure.

You made excellent points up until this sentence. On a world wide scale, a couple million dollars is not even a drop in the bucket. But it can do tremendous good locally.

In my own life, I was helped out enormously because someone loaned me just $5000 at a critical time. More broadly, one of my professors is involved in a small nonprofit that targets one poor village in Africa. Their global impact is minute, but they have already helped that village create (not given, but helped it create for itself) a school for its children. Globally, a couple of million is probably not objectively measurable, but if targetted and used well it can make an enormous difference in the lives of a smaller group of people.

timwiseman··on No matter how much "karate" you know, someone else will always know more.
I think it depends. If the original author (or most recent modifier) is available then "I don't get this code" means I should be scheduling some time to talk to them.

If the original author is completely unavailable and I am the new maintainer, then "I don't get this code" might be a valid reason to rewrite it. Even if I can't improve it, by the end of it I will know what those pitfalls are and understand that code.

timwiseman··on How to Apologize
You can't apologize for making someone feel badly about something if you still hold that something to be true.

You can if what you are apologizing for is the way or time you expressed it. Slavery is probably a controversial example because almost everyone now will agree it is morally wrong. But even absolute facts can be offensive at the wrong time.

For instance, I think more people should be aware of the extent of the dangers of drowning and the right ways to prevent it. It would be insensitive at best if I started discussing that during the funeral of a young child that had drowned. It is a good message to get out, but it would be appropriate for me to apoloize for bringing up in that context.

timwiseman··on Why Do The Labels Continue To Insist That 'Your Money Is No Good Here?'
A good publisher can provide editing, formatting, graphics, advertising, and localization.

They can also add their stamp of approval to it (I know that this means nothing to a lot of buyers, but it does mean something to some. I have heard a couple of readers of mass fiction rave about trust Del Rey books to be worth reading because they trust Del Rey), and an established publisher can more easily get it into print if/when it is worth doing.

Of course an author can do all of those themselves or hire others to handle those steps for them. But it is certainly value-added to have all of that done for you.

timwiseman··on Teacher Suspended For Reading 'Ender's Game' To Middle School Students
It depends on what you mean by right, its a very context dependent word. In one sense, rights are precisely the things which the government is not permitted to interfere with. So in that sense it really is about the ability of the state to interfere (or not) with the way a parent raises their child.

In the broader sense, it becomes somewhat hard to talk about because it might matter greatly much how old the child is. My 3 year old is simply not in an position to make many good decisions for herself, but my 6 year old gets a fair bit more freedom, and as they get older I will hand more of the reigns of their own lives to them happily.

It is also hard to talk about separately because in a sense a child's rights are what is left over after the state and the parent divide up their rights, any right absolutely given to the child is denied to one of those two entities. Should I have the ability to restrict what my 3 year old sees? I think most would agree that I should.

Should I have the ability to restrict what my 13 year old sees (when one of them reaches 13)? That is touchier, but I think most will answer, "Yes, but you should use it less and listen to their judgment more." I certainly think that even when my child turns 13 I will want to keep them away from materials that overtly objectify women and I will judge on a case by case basis if they are ready for horror films or not.

For what it's worth, I agree with your sentiment at the end that many parents overly coddle even older children. But I also respect that each parent has the privelege and duty of making those decisions for themselves and their children until those children cease to be children.

timwiseman··on Teacher Suspended For Reading 'Ender's Game' To Middle School Students
I must respectfully disagree that it is outdated drivel. First, there are large pockets of racism still present throughout the US and the world at large. Even if you are fortunate enough to live in a place where it is simply not encountered, it will be encountered if you travel much.

Second, even if and when we reach a point in society where racism is truly gone, it is useful to know how we got there. To Kill a Mocking Bird not only helps show how society was before, it was itself a small piece of history that helped in a small way make society the way it is now with less racism.

Even if we reach a utopian day where its lessons are no longer relavent (and we are not there yet), it will remain a significant aid in understanding our history.

timwiseman··on Why Do The Labels Continue To Insist That 'Your Money Is No Good Here?'
Most of what you said is true. And I, as a programmer and occassional amateur author, am quite against piracy.

Yet, the copyright holders biggest arguments for strict copyright enforcement also seem to go out the window if they make it impossible to legitimately purchase the content in a certain market. They cannot claim they have lost a sale if they have made it impossible for that sale to go through any reasonable, legitimate channel.

timwiseman··on Why Do The Labels Continue To Insist That 'Your Money Is No Good Here?'
He did, and quite eloquently. Yet, all of his reasons for caring are tied up essentially with failings of the middleman.

Based on his answer, if he could deal with a truly global middleman that could distribute throughout the world and paid him fairly for that privilege (rather than only caring about their own current region), he would probably cease to care.

timwiseman··on Teacher Suspended For Reading 'Ender's Game' To Middle School Students
I did watch A New Hope with my three year old, but the point is I decided that it was appropriate for my daughter and watched it with her so that I could explain anything she asked about and cut it off if it turned out more violent then I remembered.

I would not force the children of other parents to watch it, and I would be outraged if some government body said I couldn't show it to my three year old.

timwiseman··on Teacher Suspended For Reading 'Ender's Game' To Middle School Students
Perhaps I'm misreading the parent, but I think he said "to Kill a Mockingbird" was one of the first required readings in school that did not fall into the drivel category.
timwiseman··on Don't use bcrypt
This is true, but most programmers don't and won't ever get a deep understanding of crypto. For that large majority, it makes complete sense to ask "What do the people who do understand crypto use in a case like this?" and use that.

That kind of copying is clearly inferior to either gaining the knowledge to make an informed decision or hiring an expert to do it for you, but for most projects that need crypto neither one of those is practical. So, copying the experts is the best practical approach in most cases.

timwiseman··on Newspapers Lose $10 Dollars in Print for Every $1 Gained Online
The Tragedy of the Commons refers to the overuse of a shared commodity that takes time to renew. I do not see how this applies to newspapers.
timwiseman··on Paul Graham consistently says ‘um’ ~7 times per minute
While I have no particular training, this does not match my experience or intuition.

I think the best thing to do, when the situation permits, is to clearly think through what you want to say before you start speaking. Then you do not need filler. If you find yourself reaching for filler, then I think it is better to stop entirely until you clearly think of the next cogent thing to say.

(Note thought that filler is different from a transition phrase. A transition phrase, which might include "on the other hand" and similar phrases, don't add meaning per se but do clearly indicate you are shifting arguments slightly which can help others follow your reasoning. But that is meant to transition, not form filler, and even then transition phrases are often overused.)

← PreviousPage 3 of 28Next →