HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

spaced-out

1,179 karma · joined May 25, 2017

submissionscomments
spaced-out··on Cities turn to ‘extreme’ water recycling
No it doesn't, agriculture makes up less than 3% of California's economy and is heavily subsidized (read - money is taken from other industries are given to farmers by the government). It's tech companies, tourism, and the entertainment industry that pay for most of the infrastructure in California.
spaced-out··on Traffic cop sues city for get-out-of-jail-free cards for NYPD friends and family
Yep, politicians keep saying that most cops are good, but it seems like even the good cops are ok with stuff like this.

Whenever this topic comes up you have some people arguing that it's not a big deal. Often these people admit to having these cards and carrying them around but still insist that they aren't valuable.

Yet this system has existed for decades across the country. If these cards weren't valuable people wouldn't bother to keep printing them and handing them out. It's clear that the people carrying these cards expect that it will help them get at least a little special treatment.

spaced-out··on Software Development Ethics
>A sword can be wielded by a knight to defend the weak and innocent and serve king and country.

If you read about medieval warfare you'll see knights often used their swords on the weak and innocent at the behest of their lord. If you were a medieval blacksmith making swords during wartime, a good percent of them would end up being used for what we today would consider atrocities.

Not that there weren't ethical uses for swords too.

spaced-out··on Software Development Ethics
>I will work for fair wages; honorably guarding my reputation and my colleagues in our work practices, while respecting the intellectual contributions of others.

What does this mean? What's an example of an unfair wage?

spaced-out··on The AI PR Industrial Complex
Just one anecdote but I went to this modern art museum in Seattle last weekend that's small but well regarded: https://www.museumofmuseums.com/

I saw several mixed media pieces there (one was a diorama IIRC), which said some part of the artwork was done with Midjourney.

spaced-out··on Some employers have decided to build their own housing for workers
It because a lot of people are already struggling with the cost of housing. It's hard to tell people they should be worried about this company exploiting them, when their only other option is to pay someone else even more money to keep a roof over their head.
spaced-out··on GPT-4 gets a B on my quantum computing final exam
Does the opposite work too? What if a human doctor mis-diagnoses me but I can prove in court that an available medical grade AI would have given the correct diagnosis. Could I sue for that?
spaced-out··on People with severe mental illness have been failed by a dysfunctional system
>Just that the person has the right to choose no medical treatment. You also have that right. If a doctor says you will certainly die without treatment, you can say no. The doctor doesn't write in the note that you are fine, just that they offered and you did not want it. It's not a "game", it is the ethical and legal requirements of the role.

The issue is that the people we're talking about don't have the mental faculties to make these decisions. Do you think someone in the state they're in, barely even aware of where they are, unable to even speak or stand up straight, would be allowed to sign a legally binding contract? Of course not, any court would throw out any contract they signed because they're obviously not mentally able to make decisions like that. Same goes for decisions about their health.

spaced-out··on GPT-4 gets a B on my quantum computing final exam
>It might catch the tumor in 99.9999% of cases, better than any human doctor. But missing a malignant tumor 0.0001% of the time is unacceptable, because it spikes the hospital's malpractice costs. So every single scan still has to be reviewed manually by a doctor first, then by the AI as a fallback.

I find it hard to believe human doctors miss malignant tumors in less than 1 out of every 10 million cases.

spaced-out··on Former Meta staffer reveals she had to ‘fight for work’
You really think Meta hired this recruiter as part of some plan to keep smaller companies from being able to hire recruiters?
spaced-out··on The uncanny failures of A.I.-generated hands
It is possible to generate good quality hands with Stable Diffusion with ControlNet. Here's a video talking about generating different hand positions from models created in Blender. There's also discussions about this on r/StableDiffusion.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ptEZQrKgHAg

Now from personal experience, it's not as easy as it seems in the video. It still takes a lot of tweaking and many iterations don't come out well, but hands are definitely not an insurmountable problem.

spaced-out··on Twitter has an internal root CA problem
>Twitter was so awful before, that it relied on people to safeguard the keys to the kingdom. This is very bad practice...that can be accessed by the board of directors, the executive managers, and designated maintainers.

LOL, you realize all the PEOPLE you list as the PEOPLE who should be able to manage the keys to the kingdom are PEOPLE? Board of directors - fired on day one of Musk takeover, executive managers - many fired one day one by Musk as well, designated maintainers - for all we know they could have been fired in the purge or quit when Musk offered the 3 month severance.

All system require people to run.

spaced-out··on Meta is building a decentralized, text-based social network
>I want strong moderation and “banning” for myself. I would ideally like this to be as automatic as possible, perhaps via default blocklists that update on an ongoing basis, that I can still opt out of if I really cared to do so.

This is fine for you perhaps, but I don't want to be a moderator. I prefer social networks like, say, Hacker News where moderation is handled for me.

>Email works this way today and most people are perfectly fine with that.

Most people only use email for work and don't particularly enjoy it. They prefer to spend their free time on other social networks.

spaced-out··on No, Teen Suicide Isn’t Rising Because Life Got Objectively Worse
So the author spent the article responding to Twitter takes from journalists and looking at stats from economists who are pretty much all old and financially secure... I didn't see anywhere where the author looked at what teenagers themselves say is bothering them, either with interviews or studies. Maybe we should get their opinion before concluding that they're being irrational?
spaced-out··on The End of the English Major
"Begs the question" is an idiomatic phrase in English that works in that context.
spaced-out··on Tech’s hottest new job: Prompt engineer
No coding required...yet.

I've been playing around with generating stories with ChatGPT for a while and...English (or any natural language) is really bad at being specific. I've made progress by learning some specific words to describe the type of scene I want and how much of it I want ChatGPT to generate (such as a scene for just that evening verses a few paragraphs describing weeks of traveling). I've also started getting some intuition for when I've given ChatGPT too much info (it'll cram all the facts in in weird ways) and too little info (it'll get really random and start inserting new characters and stuff).

Having a way to manage the meta aspects of story generation would be a big help.

spaced-out··on The US Supreme Court doesn’t understand the internet
>No newspaper could take that excuse. Toys R Us couldn't say "oh jeez, we didn't realize that a corner of our store was being used by child pornographers to spread child pornography and also recruit children" and not be liable. I'm not sure why we think it's good to give an excuse to YouTube and Facebook for this and anything else anyone else would normally be liable for.

I'll admit, we may even be better off as a society of communication was less "democratized." There certainly would have been a lot less covid and election misinformation out there if every rando wasn't able to have their uninformed ideas broadcasted by giant platforms.

spaced-out··on The US Supreme Court doesn’t understand the internet
>Not sure why that's my problem, I'm not the one making money by promoting reactionary videos to reactionaries.

The reason I think we should see it as our problem is because I think the solution companies arrive at is just to turn the internet into cable TV, where only approved media organizations are able to share content because of liability concerns.

spaced-out··on The US Supreme Court doesn’t understand the internet
>The most recent, the oldest

Do you not recognize how lousy of a video sharing website this would be? Spammers are going to be constantly uploading marketing and other low-quality content with irrelevant keywords, while users that actually put work into making good quality videos will see their results pushed to the bottom quickly. How will you deal with that without implementing a system that can identify and recommend non-spam videos? Even the oldest versions of Youtube were boosting videos that got lots of likes.

>the closest match

How is deciding the "closest match" not considered a recommendation? They all have the user's keyword, what other criteria will you use?

spaced-out··on The US Supreme Court doesn’t understand the internet
>Personally I'd find it delightful if the rage-engine got smashed with a legal hammer and my Youtube recommendations were as useful as they were fifteen years ago.

Why would it be safe for them to use an older recommendation system? It doesn't solve the problem, if their older system recommends a terrorism video, even if it only did so because that video came up chronologically, they're still liable.

I would think they would need to just stop allowing the general public to upload videos anymore and only permit trusted media companies and influencers (ones known to not create controversial content) to do so. Probably after being approved through a vetting process where their lawyers can look through at least some of the content first.

spaced-out··on Museum displays artwork created by AI in place of Girl with a Pearl Earring
Damn, the CIA had good taste in art, who knew...
spaced-out··on Big Tech lobbyist language made it verbatim into NY’s hedged repair bill
> You cannot stop hackers by doubling down on the very policies they seek to amend,

You're assuming their goal is to "stop" every hacker, it's not. It's to secure this revenue stream for ag tech farm manufacturers, which they've done. They don't care if a handful of hackers fix a few tractors; if any get too big the boot comes down hard and they're ruined by fines and jail time. These changes are meant to block serious competition, by ensuring the vast majority of farmers will need to get their stuff repaired in official shops, which they still will.

>Sony, Microsoft, and Nintendo could give a doctoral lecture on this

On what? How to make tons of money all over the world for decades? Those are some of the most powerful and successful companies in history.

spaced-out··on The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/OpenAI content moderation
>Antisemitism is more common among left wingers than right wingers

Yes, I remember that left wing protest where people chanted "Jews will not replace us". Remind me, which president was it that said there were "good people" in that crowd?

spaced-out··on $6.96B was raised by private longevity companies in 2022
Depends on what country you're looking at.
spaced-out··on Two Supreme Court cases that could break the internet
>If you engage in editorializing (read: controlling) content beyond what is necessary to comply with laws and regulations (eg: no child porn, no tangible death threats), then you should be liable for the content you subsequently publish.

So how do you propose forums deal with spam?

spaced-out··on Promotion of alternative social platforms policy
>Maybe what matters to NSA bureaucrats making contracting decisions is knowing that Bezos will give them lucrative private sector jobs?

So wouldn't that mean the last thing they'd do is raise a fuss about what some random WaPo reporter, that Bezos has almost certainly never met, wrote which has probably not even gone viral? Just ignore it and give AWS the contracts...no?

spaced-out··on The Twitter Files
>It would be safe to assume that this metric is a reasonable proxy for Twitter staff's political leanings.

No it wouldn't be because it doesn't way what percent of employees donate at all. I assume the percentage is pretty low because it's <$200,000 going to Democrats from the entire company.

spaced-out··on Twitter engineer: I thought I’d been hacked. It turned out I’d been fired
This is very true, and there's certainly nothing I could do if our industry becomes filled with people who are willing and eager to put in 70 hour weeks for months at a time.

All I'd add is look where it got this guy: still fired. And I bet he got less severance than the people who opted for the 3 months from that form Musk sent out weeks ago. I started my career in startups and I saw the same thing quite often. Passionate young engineers sinking their life into a project only to get the same, or an even worse deal than the people who did less work but were more politically savvy.

spaced-out··on Twitter engineer: I thought I’d been hacked. It turned out I’d been fired
>My colleague, whom I liked a lot, was never going to get it done in time without help, so we all pitched in. I actually quite enjoyed it. I wasn’t really thinking about whether those changes were good for Twitter; I just really liked being part of that community, working together on a deadline. I even slept on a sofa in the office on Saturday night.

It's not cool to paint pressuring employees to work long hours as a good thing, and we need to be more vocal about this. It's great the author is fine wasting his weekend working on changes to a verification system that was launched for only a few days, but some of us have family and friends we like to spend time with. Hobbies and other things outside of work that give our lives meaning. Generations of workers fought hard for things like weekends and we shouldn't just glibly throw them away just because we're paid well.

spaced-out··on Twitter's top advertisers have pulled out of the platform
It was out of question in the mind of those officials, at that time. NATO was expanded under later administrations.
← PreviousPage 2 of 13Next →