HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

shkkmo

5,895 karma · joined March 29, 2014

submissionscomments
shkkmo··on Why Archers Didn't Volley Fire
Perhaps because they read the article:

> horses are big and react poorly to being wounded: a solid arrow hit on a horse is very likely to disable both horse and rider. And while light or archer cavalry might limit exposure to mass arrow fire by attacking in looser formation, as we’ve discussed, European heavy horse generally engages in very tight lines of armored men and horses in order to maximize the fear and power of their impact. Unsurprisingly then, we see from antiquity forward, efforts to armor or protect horses, called ‘barding’: defenses of thick textile, scale, lamellar, and even plate are known in various periods, though of course the more armor placed on the horse, the larger and stronger it needs to be and the slower it moves. Nevertheless, the size and shape of a horse makes it harder to armor than a human and you simply cannot achieve a level of protection for a horse that is going to match a heavy infantryman on the ground, especially if the latter has a large shield.

shkkmo··on A senior Apple exec could be jailed in Epic case
Proton is open source, so AFAIK, nobody had to pay to use it.
shkkmo··on The group chats that changed America
I hope all the partisans take a lesson from this.

When you try to force ideological conformity with censorship, you end up creating even tighter echo chambers that amplify groupthink and entrench the very ideas you are trying to combat.

The best way to defeat an idea is to publicly tolerate and dispute it.

shkkmo··on Virginia passes law to enforce maximum vehicle speeds for repeat speeders
Tickets can be disputed and many people make a livelihood without a vehicle.

I think current penalties for reckless driving are far too lenient. Driving is not a right, but a privilege. If someone chooses to use that privilege irresponsibly, they should lose that privilege.

Personally, I would advocate for a license revocal process that happens much quicker than what we do now and provides a mechanism for regaining access to that privilege through a rigorous process of eduction and community service.

shkkmo··on Uncovering the mechanics of The Games: Winter Challenge
That isn't really the same situation. The 1981 "version" is a stealth game that is pretty much completely unrelated to the 1992 game except through name, inspiration and theme.

The 1992 game was able to use the wolfenstein name because the trademark had lapsed the the original company had gone backrupt. While the 1992 game was originally intented to include stealth gameplay, none of those gameplay features from the 1981 game really made it into the final version of the 1992 game.

Key here is that M.U.S.E. sold no rights to id software, did not bless the 1992 game in any way, and there were no personel in common between the two games. They can't really be considered as part of the same franchise

shkkmo··on Google is illegally monopolizing online advertising tech, judge rules
> There's serious nerd sniping potential in asking how best to construct an automatic bidder, especially with the speed and scale requirements in place. It's an incredibly deep problem, and I don't believe there is a single right answer.

The problem is that it is unwise to trust an bidding algorithm designer whose incentives are aligned against yours. Google benefits from higher winning bids.

shkkmo··on Whistleblower details how DOGE may have taken sensitive NLRB data
Are you sure? There can be absolutely be voting and flagging biases, but the majority if the time it happens it is due to issues of tone for comments that are picking fights rather then prompting interesting discourse. When you get flagged or down voted, the most productive response is to look at how you were presenting your information or opinion and if there was a way to do so that would be more inclined to produce a productive conversation. Even when it's borderline, there's usually something you could have changed that wouldn't have drawn as much partisan ire and it is valuable to consider this, as partisan ire turns off brains.
shkkmo··on No elephants: Breakthroughs in image generation
> This was an important discussion to have two to three years ago, then we had it online, and then we more or less agreed that it's unfair for artists to have their works sucked up with no recourse.

Speak for yourself, there was no consensus online. There are plenty of us that think that dramatically expanding the power of copyright would be a huge mistake that would primarily benefit larger companies and do little to protect or fund small artists.

shkkmo··on The Importance of Fact-Checking
> In this case, the most obsequiously pro-Trump right wing news outlet in America really literally is paid Russian propaganda.

I find it crazy that a news person can, while reporting the news, qualify their statement with strengtheners like "really literally" and then claim it was an assertion of opinion, not fact.

shkkmo··on xAI has acquired X, xAI now valued at $80B
A copy left style arrangement would require you to not enforce your patents against anyone who signs and upholds the agreement, not just with Tesla. If that was the case, I probably wouldn't have quibbled with the term "open source" being applied.
shkkmo··on xAI has acquired X, xAI now valued at $80B
I'm a fan of Tesla's patent strategy. However, calling it "open source" isn't strictly correct. Patents are only free to use as long as you also give Tesla rights to all your patents.
shkkmo··on I drove 300 miles, then asked police to send me surveillance footage of my car.
Thag entirely depends on the implementation details of the access controls to that data and if the police need a warrant to access that data.
shkkmo··on In Jail Without a Lawyer: How a Texas Town Fails Poor Defendants
Being put on the sex offender registry happens after conviction. The comment you are responding to is talking about how unconvictable trumped up charges are used to scare people into taking pleas so your challenge doesn't make sense in context.
shkkmo··on Spammers are better at SPF, DKIM, and DMARC than everyone else
It's weird so see such a factually incorrect comment so high up on HN.

SPF/DKIM is literally how you establish sender identity instead of relying on the IP address of the email server so it is ironic to claim that they have anything to do with server reputation while lamenting a lack of sender reputation mechanisms.

Currently, SPF/DKIM are mostly used to prevent fraud, but they also provide the best tool we have to build sender based reputation systems.

shkkmo··on uBlock Origin is no longer available on the Chrome Store
> Does it? Or that's what the mozilla organization wastes on harebrained initiatives overall?

Mozilla Foundation spent 260 million on software development in 2023. https://assets.mozilla.net/annualreport/2024/mozilla-fdn-202...

That may include some software development on non-firefox products though.

shkkmo··on AI tools are spotting errors in research papers: inside a growing movement
> unethical researchers could run it on their own work before submitting. It could massively raise the plausibility of fraudulent papers

The real low hanging fruit that this helps with is detecting accidental errors and preventing researchers with legitimate intent from making mistakes.

Research fraud and its detection is always going to be an adversarial process between those trying to commit it and those trying to detect it. Where I see tools like this making a difference against fraud is that it may also make fraud harder to plausibly pass off as errors if the fraudster gets caught. Since the tools can improve over time, I think this increases the risk that research fraud will be detected by tools that didn't exist when the fraud was perpetrated and which will ideally lead to consequences for the fraudster. This risk will hopefully dissuade some researchers from committing fraud.

shkkmo··on Discworld Rules
The article ends with section called "Discworld Rules vs. Culture Rules" that you would probably find worth reading.
shkkmo··on Farallon Islands live (and controllable) webcam
Anyone else have some other favorite nature web cams like this they can share?
shkkmo··on TSMC expected to announce $100B investment in U.S.
Brunei isn't on the Bertelsmann because it is small (<1 million people), not because of its political structure.

The EDI explicitly does not try to asses whether a country is democratic or not, but just allows relative comparisons. It also doesn't include smaller countries but doesn't have as clear of a cutoff.

If you are going to use inclusion on one or more of these lists as an argument, you'll have actually cite where those lists use status as a democracy as a criteria for inclusion and how that is assessed.

shkkmo··on Geothermal power is a climate moon shot beneath our feet
The xenon poisoning is why they took the control rods all the way out, but the runaway reaction was probably caused by the graphite tips on the ends of the control rods. As the control rods were scrammed these tips passed through areas of high neuton flux and caused a spike in power which probably caused the explosion.

There were a lot more factors at play in the chain, but the burnoff of the xenon wasn't itself the proximal cause of the explosion.

shkkmo··on Introducing a terms of use and updated privacy notice for Firefox
> I'm more interested in making sure I fully understand a matter, often by bouncing my interpretations off other people.

Are you a lawyer?

You've been doing more than "bouncing my interpretations of other people". You've been confidently telling people that your interpretation is correct and that concerns about this granting Firefox legal cover to do much more with user data are baseless.

> navigate, experience, and interact

You claims these words are restrictive, but they really aren't.

Did you write an reddit post about air condidtioners? Does that indicate an interest in buying an air conditioner? Can mozilla now sell/share that data with advertisers so you can experience ads related to air-conditioners?

Those three words provide a huge amount of wiggle room.

If you truly want to "fully understand a matter", it hells to look at the entire context.

shkkmo··on Gene Hackman has died
That was my first thought too, but only 1 of their 3 dogs was found dead
shkkmo··on Slack Is Down
It must have been one hell of a morning. It took them 5 hours to identify the cause and everything is still broken for me.
shkkmo··on Slack Is Down
Can you send messages or see anyone online?
shkkmo··on Slack Is Down
Yeah, and the incident details indicate call it "degraded functionality" when it seems broken for everyone across the board. Desktop app, website and mobile app all non-functional.
shkkmo··on Why does target="_blank" have an underscore in front?
> because you could totally have underscores in frame names.

Technically, the underscore was restricted and should not be used for user defined targets/frame names. This isn't something any browser I know of ever enforced.

https://www.w3.org/TR/REC-html40/types.html#h-6.16

shkkmo··on Why does target="_blank" have an underscore in front? (2024)
Not just weird behavior, but possible security issues. Browsers now automatically add a rel="noopener" to links that target _blank to prevent the opened site from gaining full access to your javascript object. Targeting _new does not do this unless you explicity add the rel="noopener" yourself.

https://github.com/whatwg/html/issues/4078 https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTML/Attributes...

shkkmo··on Egg prices are soaring. Are backyard chickens the answer?
"lied through his teeth" isn't an accurate description. His openness about his history of drunking wasn't ideal and did damage his credibility. However other people have partially reproduced the health effects of what he did and his level of drinking is pretty common in the USA so it's not like he's some crazy outlier.
shkkmo··on Meta Project Aria - Smart Glasses Research Kit
> Right now people have to point their phone cameras at at the thing they're photographing

I mean, that really isn't true. There have been wearable and carryable hidden cameras for ages and we also have 360 cameras that no longer need to be pointed at what they are capturing.

This isn't changing anything about what is available to purchase, and if anything, these are relatively more obvious.

The actual change would be, that if these become widely adopted, those types of cameras would be everywhere.

shkkmo··on Migraine is more than a headache – a rethink offers hope
Without the lies our brain tells our consciousness, we couldn't function. Even core stuff like the way that we see or our experience of choice, are dependent on our brain fooling us in some way.

Luckily, we an pretty good at being hypocritical. This allows us to learn and think about this stuff while still believing the lies.

← PreviousPage 10 of 34Next →